ADVERTISEMENT

MEDIA BIAS

‘Pronoun buttons’ and ‘white man bad’ book clubs: ex-Seattle Times columnist describes newsroom culture

Ex-Seattle Times columnist Matt Calkins describes pronoun buttons, race-focused book clubs and a newsroom he says is hostile to alternative viewpoints.

Matt Calkins resigned from the Seattle Times last week after 11 years. On his way out, he described a newsroom where a reporter with a conservative opinion learns quickly to keep it to himself.

Calkins quit last Thursday after editors killed his column about two Washington girls who object to competing against biological males, the same girls a Seattle Storm co-owner allegedly cursed at courtside in an incident that got her suspended five games by the WNBA. The reason he gave for leaving was not that single decision. It was the environment that produced it, one he says shifted hard after 2020 and never shifted back.

He was careful about how he put it. Calkins repeatedly declined to name individual editors and went out of his way to compliment his former colleagues. But what he described anyway should worry anyone who still pays for a subscription.

Buttons at the door and book clubs about race

Asked to characterize the culture across the newsroom and the opinion section, Calkins made it clear which side of the political spectrum the staff seemed expected to be on.

“It’s a very far-left culture. I mean, there are pronoun buttons when you walk in the door that you’re strongly encouraged to wear, and we had book clubs where basically it was all about race, like ‘White Fragility’ or Ibram Kendi, and it’s basically kind of the whole white man bad kind of thing, and they kept beating that drum with every book that we read,” Calkins said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

ADVERTISEMENT

He suspects plenty of people in the building privately agree with him and have simply calculated that silence is cheaper.

“It’s not conducive to someone who thinks a little differently, and you kind of get that feeling when you walk in the building sometimes,” he added.

His solution was avoidance. He stopped showing up.

“I didn’t go into the office much, and I kind of stayed away from a lot of the parties and stuff, and meetings and the quarterly meetings we had, just because I didn’t necessarily feel comfortable there,” Calkins recalled. “I didn’t know that me speaking up on anything would help at all.”

What changed after 2020?

Calkins joined the paper more than a decade ago, and he says the place he left is not the place he was hired into.

“It was definitely different in 2020 than it was in 2015, as I think it was probably across newsrooms everywhere,” he observed. “You really felt that they were kind of committed to an ideology, committed to certain movements, and dissenting against those movements just didn’t sit right with them.”

ADVERTISEMENT

That commitment shows up in the product. The paper has rewritten three convicted federal defendants into civil rights martyrs, turned a World Cup celebration into a Trump grievance session, and argued the SAVE Act was a partisan Republican plot while simultaneously reporting that it would hurt Republican voters most.

The paper of record problem

Calkins’ objection is not that the Seattle Times leans left. It is that a monopoly paper in a one-party city acts like a cable channel and still calls itself the paper of record.

“I look at someone like MS NOW. They are catering toward a liberal audience, and they don’t necessarily feel obligated to get other points of view in there,” he said. “But when you’re the paper of record for a major city, which is obviously a very left-leaning city, I still think if you’re the paper of record, you should do whatever you can to get alternative views in there. And I just didn’t really see them very often, and my guess is you don’t either.”

ADVERTISEMENT

He said the editor-in-chief has expressed a wish for more variety in the pages. Calkins does not think much was done to get it. Asked what he will do without mandatory social justice training, he had a sarcastic answer ready.

“Yeah, the DEI counseling, it’s going to be a little rough. I don’t know what I’m going to do. I’m probably going to become a lot less empathetic,” he joked.

He still praised the reporting staff, singling out Seahawks writer Bob Condotta and Mariners writer Ryan Divish, and said he plans to keep reading them. The talent was never the problem. The talent is stuck working for editors who decided some Washington residents are not worth quoting.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

4 Comments

C
Candis Gauvin 3 months ago

This is a common theme throughout the msm

G
Grog Knuckledragger 3 months ago

Good for Matt for taking the high road.

D
Doug Spittler 3 months ago

“I will add, that the man who never looks into a newspaper is better informed than he who reads them; inasmuch as he who knows nothing is nearer to truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods & errors. He who reads nothing will still learn the great facts, and the details are all false.” ~ T. Jefferson, June 11, 1807

Is it only coincidence that 36% of "journalists" self-identify as Dimocrats as opposed to 27% of the general population?