ADVERTISEMENT

MEDIA BIAS

Seattle Times killed Matt Calkins’ column on protecting girls’ sports. He walked out that afternoon.

Matt Calkins resigned from the Seattle Times after editors spiked his column on girls' sports, the fourth of his columns the paper had killed in recent years.

The Seattle Times logo mounted on a concrete exterior wall...

UW professor Cliff Mass says a Seattle Times Climate Lab story on Skagit River flooding ignored federal flow data. (Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)

(Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)

Matt Calkins spent 11 years as a sports columnist at the Seattle Times. He resigned the afternoon his editors told him a column about two Washington girls who object to competing against biological males would never see print.

The column grew out of a rally outside Climate Pledge Arena late last month, held in support of Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham before her team faced the Seattle Storm. Calkins interviewed two teenage athletes there, including 16-year-old Ahnaleigh Wilson, who lost to a biological male in an eighth grade track race, and Frances Staudt, who says she has taken daily abuse since refusing to play a basketball game against a biological boy. Wilson was one of the girls a Storm co-owner allegedly cursed at courtside during the game, an incident that drew a fine from the WNBA and a five-game suspension for co-owner Celeste Keaton. A coalition of women’s sports groups and Olympians later demanded accountability from the Storm and the league.

Calkins filed his draft on Friday, July 31. What happened over the next six days is why he no longer works there.

Six days, two editors, and no feedback at all

Calkins told his editor there was no rush. The column sat while it moved up the chain, and he heard nothing back about its content.

“Submitted the column Friday. I said, ‘you don’t need to rush this out. This isn’t my surprise Sunday column.’ They said, ‘okay, well, we’re going to look at it, but we’re not going to run it for Sunday,'” Calkins recounted on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “And on Monday, I got an email from my editor saying that his boss was going to look at it, take it to the top two editors on Wednesday.”

The answer came Thursday afternoon, and the reason given had nothing to do with what he wrote.

“And then on Thursday, I got a call saying, you didn’t tell us what you were doing beforehand, and we’re not going to run this piece. And I was prepared for something like that, and I said, ‘okay, I don’t think I could work there anymore,'” he said.

ADVERTISEMENT

He does not buy the explanation.

“So, never to me did I feel like this was spiked on command or on sight just because I didn’t tell them that it was coming right away. It seemed like kind of a lame excuse,” Calkins said.

Asked directly whether the content was the real reason, he did not hesistate.

“I’m almost sure it was, because anytime I’ve tried to go against the grain there, that tends to be what happens,” he answered.

The column was not even an argument against trans athletes

The piece the Seattle Times would not run was considerably milder than its handling suggests. Calkins was not calling for a ban. He was reporting what two girls told him and asking people to knock off the name-calling.

ADVERTISEMENT

“They’re like, ‘no, this is not anti-trans. We don’t have anything against trans people. We just want our own spaces.’ And that was the premise. That was the takeaway,” he explained. “My main takeaway was let’s stop throwing these labels around, transphobic, bigot, when people are trying to have an honest conversation about a delicate topic.”

The silence bothered him as much as the decision.

“The fact that I never got an ounce of feedback over the six days was very weird to me,” Calkins noted.

Four columns buried, one resignation

This was the fourth column of his the paper had killed. Earlier casualties included a piece questioning the equal-pay discrimination claims made by the U.S. Women’s National Team, a column on cancel culture in sports, and one written after George Floyd’s death urging readers to listen to state champion basketball coach Mike Bethea, a black man asking the public not to stereotype police.

ADVERTISEMENT

Calkins walked away from a salary, a beat he loved, and a seat at the Super Bowl. He wrote on his Substack that he is scared about what comes next, and he said the same thing on air.

“But I do have a steady paycheck, I do get to go to the Super Bowl, I did get to do all this stuff, but ultimately I said, the only way for me to get rid of this feeling is to make a change, and I just felt like I had to do it,” he said. “I think it’s worth the dice roll to see what else is out there, to see if there’s an outlet where I can be more myself.”

He also rejected any suggestion that this was a tantrum.

“And as I said in my Substack piece, it might have sounded like a rage quit kind of thing. It wasn’t. It was something that I’d been thinking about for a while,” Calkins said.

The timing is not incidental. Washington voters decide Initiative IL26-638 in November, a measure reserving girls’ sports for biological females, and the U.S. Supreme Court upheld similar laws in Idaho and West Virginia in June. The largest newspaper in the state had a columnist who talked to the girls at the center of it, and it decided readers were better off not hearing from them.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 3 months ago

The Seattle Times has been front and center of this city's current decline, guilty of every charge you could throw at them: lack of journalistic integrity, betrayal of public trust, and just plain cowardice and laziness. The biggest shame is how the entire state has to be dragged down as well, when all The Seattle Times had to do was their job. Good for Matt Calkins on leaving, if I had a job to offer him it would be offered.

N
Nolan Void 3 months ago

I’m so old I remember when the Seattle Times reported the news.

It’s been a while.