ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: The Seattle Times claims SAVE Act hurts Republicans, forgetting it spent months saying the opposite

The Seattle Times argued the SAVE Act hurts Republican voters — accidentally destroying its own claim that the bill is a partisan scheme against Democrats.

The Seattle Times logo mounted on a concrete exterior wall...

UW professor Cliff Mass says a Seattle Times Climate Lab story on Skagit River flooding ignored federal flow data. (Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)

(Photo: Linda Thomas, KIRO Newsradio)

The Seattle Times published a piece this week arguing that President Donald Trump’s push to restrict mail-in voting would hurt Republican voters in Washington state more than Democratic ones. Nobody in the newsroom appears to have noticed the problem with that.

For months, left-wing media and talking heads have insisted the SAVE America Act is a cynical partisan maneuver, a Republican scheme designed to entrench GOP power at the expense of everyone else. Now, they’re arguing the opposite. Rural voters in red districts like Washington’s 4th Congressional District would have farther to travel to cast ballots than their counterparts in solidly blue Puget Sound districts. The paper treats this as a damning revelation about Trump’s strategy.

So if the bill hurts the Republican base in Eastern Washington just as much as anyone else, what was the partisan scheme exactly?

The argument the Seattle Times can’t keep straight

This is not a small logical gap. The paper declared the bill “voter suppression” weeks ago, recycling Democratic talking points about how the SAVE Act was engineered to benefit Republicans. Now it’s publishing analysis that says the bill’s burdens fall heaviest on those same Republican voters. Both of those things cannot be true at once.

The simpler answer is the right one. The SAVE Act is a universal requirement. It applies to every voter regardless of party, district, or zip code. Rural voters of any affiliation face longer drives to voting centers than urban voters. That’s a real policy concern worth debating. What it isn’t is a conspiracy.

Rep. Michael Baumgartner (R-Spokane), a supporter the bill, told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM: “It certainly should not be difficult to make sure that you’re an American citizen and you have ID to be able to vote.” The standard he’s describing applies to a Republican rancher in Yakima County and a Democratic renter in Capitol Hill exactly the same way.

ADVERTISEMENT

The outsourced race angle

The second problem with the piece is harder to miss once you see it.

Rather than directly argue that Black voters are disproportionately unlikely to have identification, the Times links to a Capital B News article about Black elders who lack birth certificates and lets that do the work. The implication is clear. The Times just didn’t want to put its name on it.

The audience the Times claims to be protecting doesn’t share its concern. A Pew Research Center poll found 76 percent of Black voters support requiring photo ID to vote. Eighty-three percent of Americans overall agreed. The left has been running this condescending argument for years, and the polling has never supported it.

The piece also leans heavily on state elections director Stuart Holmes, who has been making the rounds warning about implementation complications. His logistics concerns are worth taking seriously. His framing that noncitizen voting essentially doesn’t happen is not. The DOJ convicted a Colombian national in 2024 for voting illegally in the presidential election while simultaneously collecting over $400,000 in federal benefits. The “fraud never happens” argument keeps running into actual cases showing it does.

ADVERTISEMENT

There was a legitimate, straightforward story here about the practical burdens the SAVE Act places on rural voters. The Times had the data to tell it. Instead the paper tried to stretch that data into confirmation of a narrative it’s been pushing since January. The data didn’t cooperate.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

C
Clockwork Wyrm 7 months ago

Say want you want about Canada's politics, they have a pretty robust and reliable voting system which is standardized across the country, requires ID, has easy info updating when filing taxes, provides a voter card prior to elections which features poling times/locations and also acts as a voting ID, uses serialized paper ballots that have a double-check confirmation system, ballots are sealed in numbered and IDed ballot boxes, and a tandem counters open ballot boxes to hand count each paper ballot in front of a room of witnesses.

Voter ID is a no-brainer great start to cleaning up our US voting system.