ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Washington won’t warn her mom before she wrestles a male again, so this Puyallup teen is suing to force it

Puyallup wrestler who says she was assaulted by a male opponent during a girls match asks the 9th Circuit to let her compete without facing male athletes.

Kallie Keeler and her mother...

Kallie Keeler and her mother have asked the 9th Circuit to block Washington from matching her against male wrestlers. (Alliance Defending Freedom)

(Alliance Defending Freedom)

A Puyallup teenage wrestler who says she was sexually assaulted after being unknowingly matched against a male opponent is asking the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to let her back on the mat without facing another male athlete.

Kallie Keeler and her mother, Stephanie Brown, filed their opening appellate brief Tuesday. They are challenging U.S. District Judge David Castillo’s August 23 refusal to grant a preliminary injunction against the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA), the Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction (OSPI) and the Puyallup School District. Attorneys with Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) represent the family.

The case has become a direct challenge to Washington rules that let transgender athletes compete according to gender identity. The WIAA handbook allows students to participate in programs consistent with their gender identity or the gender they most consistently express.

How the case started

Keeler was 15 and wrestling for Rogers High School when she competed at Emerald Ridge High School in December 2025. According to the lawsuit, neither Keeler nor Brown knew her opponent was male.

Keeler alleges the opponent digitally penetrated her during the match and later touched her again. She eventually allowed herself to be pinned. Brown reported the incident to school officials two days later.

Law enforcement did not hear about it for another 53 days. In July, Rogers High School Principal Jason Smith and athletic coordinator Peter Collins were charged in Pierce County District Court with failing to comply with Washington’s mandatory reporting law.

ADVERTISEMENT

Seattle Red reported earlier this year that the U.S. Department of Education opened a Title IX investigation into the Puyallup School District. Pierce County prosecutors later declined to charge the opponent, concluding they could not prove a crime beyond a reasonable doubt under Washington case law governing consent and physical contact during athletic competition.

The family sued in June.

‘No girl should have to choose’

The appellate brief opens by going after Washington’s policy.

“No girl should have to choose between playing the sports she loves and her safety. But Washington forces female athletes to compete on unsafe, uneven playing fields,” the attorneys wrote. “The result? High-school females must face males with inherent advantages, while males get to compete against physiological counterparts on fair footing. And parents cannot make decisions to protect their daughters’ health and safety.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Brown is asking for one of two things. School officials could give her advance notice when her daughter is matched against a male, or they could automatically withdraw her daughter from those matches without penalty.

ADF argues the dispute comes down to parental authority.

“Brown asks to make one such decision here: whether her 15-year-old daughter wrestles a male. That decision belongs to her alone,” the brief states.

A judge said no

As Seattle Red reported after the August injunction hearing in Tacoma, the family sought the injunction so Keeler could get back to competing. Castillo denied it. According to the appellate brief, the judge characterized Brown’s parental-rights claim as an attempt to direct school athletics and obtain sensitive information about other students.

ADF counters that the defendants have created an opt-out Brown has no practical way to use.

“They won’t schedule around the match. They won’t tell Brown one is coming. And they won’t withhold K.M.K. on their own,” the brief says. “An opt-out Defendants will not implement is no opt-out at all.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Earlier this month, ADF filed an emergency motion asking the 9th Circuit to act by September 25. The family wants the appeals court to reverse Castillo and order a preliminary injunction while the underlying lawsuit moves forward.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

2 Comments

J
Jake Morningwood 2 months ago

The institutional misogyny of this state astounds me. And when it applies to teen girls it is nothing short of child abuse.

R
Ray Corcoles 2 months ago

The Transgender movement is a special interest group which makes it unconstitutional to push legislation to accommodate.