ADVERTISEMENT

GUN RIGHTS

Appeals court ruling could reopen the door for Washington residents who qualified for gun rights before the 2023 crackdown

A Washington appeals court ruled a man who qualified to restore his gun rights before 2023 must be judged under the old law, not the new restitution rule.

gun range...

The Washington Court of Appeals ruled the state's 2023 restitution requirement cannot be used against a man who qualified to restore his gun rights under the old law. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

A Washington man is one step closer to regaining his right to bear arms after taking his case through multiple courts.

Jerry McCaulley lost his firearm rights after being convicted of vehicular assault in February 2014. Under Washington state law, a person generally loses their firearm rights after being convicted of a felony. Before a 2023 amendment, eligible individuals could regain those rights after completing certain conditions of their sentence and remaining crime-free for five years.

Under the current law, applicants must also pay their court-ordered restitution in full.

He qualified before the rules changed

McCaulley had qualified to regain his firearm rights for years before the statute was changed. He had remained crime-free and completed the other requirements of his sentence. However, McCaulley was originally ordered to pay $153,779.80 in restitution, which prevented him from qualifying under the newer law.

He argued that the court should apply the previous statute because he had qualified under it while it was still in effect, even though he had not successfully petitioned for his rights before the law changed.

McCaulley first petitioned for restoration in December 2023, but that petition was apparently dismissed. He filed another petition on Aug. 18, 2025, which was denied on Oct. 3, 2025.

Appeals court sends the case back under the old law

McCaulley appealed to the Washington Supreme Court, which transferred the case to the Washington Court of Appeals. On Aug. 31, 2026, the Court of Appeals reversed the lower court’s decision and ordered it to reconsider his petition under the previous law. The appellate court ordered its opinion published on Nov. 3, giving the ruling precedential significance.

ADVERTISEMENT

The appeals court reached its decision after citing State v. T.K., a 1999 Washington Supreme Court case involving the vacation of juvenile records. That case established that eligibility for statutory relief can depend on when a person meets the requirements, rather than when they make the request to a court.

The court also cited State v. Dennis, a 2018 case involving the restoration of firearm rights.

The requirement to pay restitution in full to recover gun rights remains in effect. However, this ruling protects people who qualified under the previous statute before the 2023 changes took effect, including McCaulley.

McCaulley has been without his firearm rights for more than a decade and has spent years fighting to regain them. Other Washington residents could be facing similar restrictions despite having qualified under the previous law.

The ruling establishes an important precedent for gun owners seeking to restore their rights in Washington state.

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments