ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ

Rantz: City of Seattle paid gun violence groups millions with no way to prove they worked

Seattle CARE chief Amy Barden says nine violence intervention contracts had no real metrics, and groups that refuse to work with police will lose funding.

Watch: "These kids are going to die young": Seattle CARE chief says the city gutted accountability | 19 mins

Seattle’s community violence intervention groups have collected taxpayer dollars for years without any real system to prove they reduce shootings, according to the official about to take over their contracts. Amy Barden, chief of the Community Assisted Response and Engagement (CARE) Department, says the arrangement has operated largely on trust.

Mayor Katie Wilson’s proposed 2027 budget moves more than $5 million a year in contracts with nine community violence intervention organizations from the Human Services Department (HSD) to CARE, the department that operates Seattle’s 911 center. HSD spent $58.8 million on violence prevention, community safety and crime survivor support in 2024 alone. The shift is part of a gun violence plan that adds no new police officers.

ADVERTISEMENT

Barden says the point of the transfer is to build the performance metrics that never existed. And she has a warning for groups that won’t work with police.

Contracts built on the honor system

Asked why metrics weren’t already in place under the former mayor and through now, Barden blamed rushed contracting inside a department juggling homelessness and other social programs.

“I think it was just hasty. You know, I’ve been talking to the team in the Human Services Department, and you’ve got to remember they’ve got hundreds of millions of dollars of contracts, homeless response, you know, all of these different really challenging societal issues. They’re not necessarily expert in public safety issues or community violence interruption. It’s just, you know, there’ll be a new elected in office, ‘Oh, we want to do CVI [community violence intervention] work,’ make some contracts, and you’ve got to have expertise to actually know what are those metrics,” Barden said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pressed on whether HSD tracked anything at all, she compared the setup to the Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) program.

“It’s kind of on the honor system. I think that’s the part that’s challenging is that you can say, it’s very similar to LEAD, you can see, ‘Oh, I’ve got this many people, 67 people are under case management.’ What does that mean? What does that actually mean? And what I’m always stressing is I want to see directional improvement. If we’re getting an intervention right, I accept it’s not overnight, but if you can see there’s more criminal behavior than ever in three or six months, try something else. If diversion fails, then you absolutely need to use a coercive intervention, right?” she replied.

The groups provide conflict mediation, hospital-based support for gunshot victims at Harborview Medical Center, outreach in neighborhoods after shootings and intensive intervention for people considered most connected to gun violence, according to the mayor’s plan.

ADVERTISEMENT

Work with police or lose the money

Seattle has been burned before. The city paused its work with the Southeast Network, a violence intervention program, after its former executive director Marty Jackson was federally charged with allegedly laundering money for relatives prosecutors say led a fentanyl trafficking ring, KOMO News reported.

Barden said a failing group won’t get a long leash under CARE.

“I’m not waiting any time at all, Jason. Like I have really big feelings about fiscal responsibility. We should not be wasting taxpayer dollars. I also really care about people. I know what the interventions that work look like, and I don’t have any patience for failing our young people, right?” Barden said.

The bigger fight may be cooperation. Barden revealed that her husband, a 38-year veteran of local law enforcement, told her the model would fail in Seattle because the nonprofits refuse to partner with police.

ADVERTISEMENT

“And I said, ‘Well, if they’re not going to be willing to partner, then they can’t really have the contracts, because that’s the design of focused deterrence.’ And I had to set the CARE pilot up that way in 2023. If you wanted to be an alternative responder, a crisis responder, you couldn’t not be supportive of law enforcement and the fire department,” Barden recounted.

She said cutting a contract would be her call once the money moves. The transfer still needs City Council approval as part of the 2027 budget, and the contracts would not come under CARE until next year.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

8 Comments

S
scotty icicle 2 months ago

sick of all this money wasted on hugs and worthless think tanks...Bring the receipts or lose the money. Sick of these pathetic excuses..It was 'rushed'? laughable...incompetent or grift is the truth

A
archie bunker 2 months ago

Money down the drain. "non-profits" can profit like crazy, just the money can go to bloated salaries. How about spend the money to hire police? Or just don't squander the money? How about just enforce the laws?

G
Gunnar gunnar 2 months ago

Jason it is a scam. You know what these "non-profits" pay there management teams>we all know the solution but they refuse to implement. Enforce current laws make violent crime pay. These judges just let them go and drop charges.
I know why because it cost $$. But yet they have enough to pay these groups of their of donors.