Rantz: Sound Transit needs four years to install a turnstile, a device New York figured out in 1904. And it will still fail.
Sound Transit approved fare gates at up to 14 Link stations, then scheduled installation for 2029 or 2030. Jason Rantz on why paying riders foot the bill.
A headshot of Burien Council member Stephanie Mora superimposed over a Sound Transit station. Sound Transit approved fare gates at up to 14 Link light rail stations, but riders will not see them until the end of the decade. (Photo: Chris Sullivan, KIRO Newsradio)
(Photo: Chris Sullivan, KIRO Newsradio)
Sound Transit’s board approved fare gates at up to 14 Link light rail stations last week, and the agency says installation is targeted for 2029 or 2030. Four years to bolt down turnstiles that already exist in nearly every serious transit system on earth.
This timeline tells you everything you need to know about Sound Transit’s many failures.
The problem the turnstiles is meant to target is supposed to be urgent. Only about 63% of Link riders actually pay, according to reporting on the board’s vote, which means better than a third of the people on that train are riding on our dime. Sound Transit’s estimate says gates could add up to $82.7 million a year in net fare revenue and break even on capital and operating costs in two to three years. The agency is simultaneously trying to explain away a $34.5 billion shortfall in the ST3 program it already taxed you for.
So, Sound Transit has identified free money, agreed it should collect that money, and then scheduled the collection for the end of the decade. I would love to believe 2029 is a real date, but nothing this agency has ever done suggests it is.
Four years to buy a gate? Really?
Good luck reading the agency’s own timeline and trying not to laugh.
“Now that the pilot is approved, Sound Transit will begin the contracting process to manufacture, deliver, and install gates at up to 14 stations on the 1 Line and 2 Line,” Sound Transit wrote in the blog post announcing the vote. “All of this will take a few years to develop.”
Before any of that happens, staff will spend until the end of 2027 producing a Fare Gate Pilot Evaluation Framework for the board to approve. That is roughly 16 months of meetings to write down what success looks like for a device that either lets you through or does not. Then comes procurement. Then comes public engagement strategy. Then, eventually, maybe, a gate.
And while this process takes years, the costs will grow and in 2029, Sound Transit will explain the costs have gone up because of inflation and costs of goods.
Los Angeles, Philadelphia, and San Francisco have all moved on gates in recent years, while New York has had turnstiles since Woodrow Wilson was president. None of them treated the turnstile as an unsolved engineering mystery requiring a multi-year discovery process.
The excuse is already written
Sound Transit says the first phase must address challenges it has not had to consider before, including ADA compliance and accessibility in fare gate designs, plus new fare media for riders who qualify for reduced fare permits and youth riders who do not currently carry it. Let’s call this Herculean without rolling our eyes.
Every one of those other cities solved accessibility issues years ago with an accessible gate at the end of the row. What Sound Transit is describing is not a technical obstacle. It is permission for inevitable delays, and it is the same reason they never deliver on their projects, except the inevitable excuse as to why they can’t deliver on time or on budget.
Sound Transit projects are late and over budget as a matter of standard operating procedure. Assume gates by 2035 and a price tag that doubles somewhere in year three, and you will be closer to reality than the agency’s press release.
They spent years calling this racist
The part Sound Transit’s announcement carefully avoids is why Link never had gates to begin with. The agency’s story is that early studies found gates would cost more than they would recover, which is the polite version. The impolite version is that Sound Transit spent years treating fare enforcement as a civil rights problem, ended enforcement in 2018 amid their own invented racial discrimination complaints, and replaced officers with fare ambassadors who could not issue a citation. Seattle Red documented the agency’s quiet reversal when the gate pilot first surfaced.
Dow Constantine pushed the 2018 legislation that softened fare enforcement while he chaired the Sound Transit board. He is now the agency’s CEO, and he is presiding over the cleanup of his own policy. Nobody has apologized to the riders who paid every single time while the agency told them enforcement was the moral failing.
Riders pay for the delay
Every year without gates is another year of service the agency cannot afford.
Mass transit ridership across Puget Sound transit has fallen even as funding nearly doubled, and Sound Transit’s farebox recovery target of 22% is not being met by a system where a third of riders skip the fare.
The people hurt by this are the saps who tap their ORCA card at 6 a.m. and then wait longer for a train because the revenue is not there. Sound Transit had four years to make that right. It chose to spend them on frameworks.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
11 Comments
Sound Transit is as corrupt an organization as you can get. The light rail system should have never been built, it is a multi-billion dollar waste of money. The turnstiles should have been built and installed in all the stations when the stations were built, not after the fact. It also shouldn't be that hard to install a fence and security turnstiles that cannot be bypassed unless you pay, at all the stations.
They failed to do this earlier because fare evaders have demographics that are awkward….lacking racial “equity”.
Gotta figure out which crony organization gets them the most bang. Remember Dori talking about city of Seattle stop sign installs costing $13,000 each to install? Good grief.