ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Seattle’s war on cars squeezed 20,000 drivers into one Denny Way lane to save the ‘late 8’

Seattle handed a Denny Way lane to Route 8 and pushed 20,000 drivers into what's left. The bus will still be late, writes Jason Rantz, and the tax is doubling.

Watch: Seattle INTENTIONALLY Makes Traffic Worse | 10 mins

Seattle finished painting a lane of Denny Way red for a bus line that will always run late, and city officials expect drivers to be grateful for the privilege to drive an already-busy stretch even slower than before. The city of Seattle is continuing its war on cars with the dumbest project to date.

The new bus-only lane opened officially on one of the two busiest surface streets in the city, paid for by the Seattle Transit Measure sales tax that voters approved and will be asked to double this November. Eastbound drivers headed for southbound I-5 can no longer cut through on Yale Avenue and are pushed instead onto Boren Avenue and Howell Street. About 20,000 other vehicles a day now squeeze into what is left, according to MyNorthwest, while buses on that stretch carry roughly 7,000 people.

ADVERTISEMENT

The case for taking the lane rests entirely on the claim that Route 8 is chronically late. That part is true, though that has almost nothing to do with the stretch of Denny impacted by the bus-only lane. This move is about punishing South Lake Union and forcing people out of their cars, the oft-used strategy of anti-car Seattle staff who want to socially engineer a way out of the plummeting bus use in the region.

Why the late 8 is actually late

I walked my dog past Denny Park two Sundays ago, after the signage and the big red block letters went up, and traffic was already backed up. Sunday. On Denny. A street that normally moves fine on a weekend was a mess before the restriction even took effect.

Route 8 does not fall behind schedule on those few blocks. It falls behind deeper into Capitol Hill, where boarding slows to a crawl as drug addicted riders get on and off, where there are few lanes and much traffic, and where one stop can cost a driver more time than the whole Denny stretch.

ADVERTISEMENT

Traffic on those blocks in South Lake Union plays a small role in tardiness. The bulk of the delay happens elsewhere.

If congestion were the culprit, someone at the city could explain Route 70, which runs through downtown streets where cars are restricted in the morning anyway, does not sit in gridlock, and is late nearly every time I ride it. Metro is being sold as the alternative before anyone fixed the product.

The people designing your commute do not drive

Back when Seattle transportation policy was one of my regular beats, the Seattle Department of Transportation invited me downtown for a tour, hoping a little hospitality would soften the coverage. Very pleasant people, who clearly loathed me, walked me through the signal operation and the street design work. Not one of them drove. No cars, no commutes, no experience with the conditions they were designing for everyone else.

I did not own a car at the time either, so this is not a purity test. It is a warning about what happens when the people writing the rules have never once been stuck in the outcome.

ADVERTISEMENT

These are the same officials who lecture everyone else about how a team needs diversity because different life experiences allow them to see a problem clearly. That principle apparently stops at the traffic engineering office, where the perspective of the overwhelming majority of road users counts for nothing.

The city’s numbers do not make it through the first commute

Mayor Katie Wilson has her talking points ready.

“This road design is going to move people more efficiently,” Wilson said, per KOMO. “The new route for drivers was tested during recent road closures. The resulting data showed the same number of drivers entering I-5 south during peak hours and travel times on eastbound Denny Way improving up to 15%. This is about making this corridor functional.”

Alex Hudson, a senior policy advisor in Wilson’s office and a noted anti-car activists, made a similar promise.

ADVERTISEMENT

“What we saw was contrary to what you might think,” Hudson said. “Travel times for riders and drivers decreased by 15%, so that’s shaving a lot of minutes off your drive time.”

Modeling a temporary closure is not the same as permanently deleting capacity on a corridor that feeds the freeway. And none of the tests they ran involved blocking access to Denny from Lenora, the way their final product delivers. Drivers heading to I-5 in that part of town have two realistic options, Mercer or Denny, and the city just degraded one of them even further, after previously blocking right turns on Westlake to Denny. Ask anyone who sat on Denny this past week whether the drive got 15% shorter.

Everett, Eastlake and the lanes nobody asked for

South Lake Union is not alone. Bike and transit lanes go in all over the region on streets where nobody rides a bike and the buses were never stuck, and the capacity comes out of the people actually using the road.

ADVERTISEMENT

It has been happening outside our own building on Eastlake for more than a year, a bus and bike lane under construction on a stretch where buses literally never get delayed. I ride that bus. If the project helped me I would say so happily, because I hate sitting in traffic as much as anyone does. But they invented a problem to justify their urbanist-at-all-cost, anti-car agenda that they’re spending millions on. This project will also make traffic worse because it is the goal.

This is the same city government that recommitted to the war on cars on Rainier Avenue South while SDOT fell behind on delivery targets for a $1.55 billion levy voters already funded and the council ordered an audit of Vision Zero.

Now Seattle wants voters to double the sales tax funding this work in November, from .15% to .3%, worth an estimated $138 million a year for the next decade. Before anyone signs off on that, the city should be made to explain why the 8 is still late in December after taking a lane it never needed. My guess is that the answer will be another lane.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

4 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 3 months ago

Bus only 3rd avenue Downtown is also one of the worst streets in the city, as you'll still see addicts on the sidewalk to this day, yet Seattle wants people to stop driving their cars so that people can take a bus Downtown only to get dropped off by the bus on a notoriously sketchy street.

It's the type of planning you would expect from a woman in her 40s with no accomplishments who lives off her parents.

H
H Chasen 3 months ago

"Don't look at the woman behind the curtain!"

~ Katie

B
Blaine G. 3 months ago

Get ready, Pierce County, the plans are in place to do exactly THIS on Pacific Ave. Eventually, from Tacoma to out past 260th on Mtn Hwy.