‘We do not verify arguments for truth or fact’: Washington SOS punts on income tax pamphlet lies
Let's Go Washington and Sen. Chris Gildon say the no campaign on I-645 printed a false claim in Washington's voters' pamphlet. The state won't fix it.
Let's Go Washington and Sen. Chris Gildon say opponents of Initiative 645 put a false claim in Washington's official voters' pamphlet. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)
Washington’s Secretary of State will print whatever the income tax campaign wants to tell voters, accurate or not, and the office is not shy about admitting it. This is not new and is equally applied regardless of the issue or candidate. But it’s come under another spotlight as Let’s Go Washington and state Sen. Chris Gildon (R-Puyallup) say the no campaign against Initiative 645 used that freedom to put a false claim in the official voters’ pamphlet.
The dispute centers on the rebuttal statement filed by opponents of I-645, the measure repealing the 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million that Gov. Bob Ferguson signed in March. According to a release the campaign sent Thursday morning, the rebuttal tells voters that any future change to Washington’s income-tax law would be decided on the ballot, and that voters always have the final say.
No provision of state law says that. A future Legislature can enact or expand an income tax the same way this one did, through a floor vote and a governor’s signature. Gildon, who chairs the Yes on I-645 ballot-statement committee, took the problem to the Elections Division.
The state says it does not check
Gildon emailed the voters’ pamphlet team on Aug. 18 and asked whether opponents were permitted to print something demonstrably untrue.
“Are they allowed to literally put a lie in their rebuttal statement?” he wrote. “There is no requirement for an expanded income tax to be put on the ballot. It simply requires legislative action. That is a blatantly false and incorrect statement.”
The Elections Division replied the next morning, according to a screenshot of the email.
“Thank you for your feedback. We do not verify arguments for truth or fact, nor is any new material accepted,” the office wrote. “Please notify us if your committee sees any discrepancies in your argument and the information you submitted.”
That is the entire review process. The state will confirm a committee’s submission matches what the committee turned in. Whether the sentences are true is somebody else’s problem, and the pamphlet still goes to every registered voter in Washington.
Sen. Gildon calls out the ballot argument
Gildon did not dispute the right of the opposition to make its case. He disputed the right to make one up.
“The opposition is free to argue against I-645,” Gildon said in a release. “But voters should not be told that future changes to income-tax law must go to the ballot. That is simply not true.”
He also told voters to go around the pamphlet.
“Washington voters deserve clear, accurate information as they consider this measure,” Gildon said. “Because committee-written arguments are not independently verified, voters should read the full initiative and the official explanatory materials before casting their ballot.”
More claims the campaign disputes
The rebuttal statement is not the only piece Let’s Go Washington flagged. Opponents also tell voters that passing I-645 would bring back a sales tax on diapers, raise taxes on hundreds of thousands of working families, and put small-business tax relief at risk.
The Attorney General’s own explanatory statement even disputes that. It says the credits, exemptions and deductions the Legislature enacted alongside the income tax survive the repeal and stay on the books.
Washington voters have already been down this road once this summer. Attorney General Nick Brown’s office wrote the one-sentence ballot disclosure warning that I-645 cuts school funding, a claim that runs into the awkward fact that the tax collects nothing until 2029. A Thurston County judge locked that language into place on Aug. 7 without hearing from the campaign that sued over it.
Now the pamphlet comes with its own unverified claims, written by a campaign funded almost entirely by public sector unions that stand to collect from the revenue. Let’s Go Washington says it will keep correcting the record and is asking voters to approve all three of its measures in November.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
3 Comments
We can hope voters will educate themselves on the issues before they vote.
Almost nothing issuing forth from Olympia has even the remotest relationship with either "truth" or "fact."
It's their money and they want it NOW! They don't care what we think, they are Statists and believe that they know what is best... I'm done... Leaving as fast as I can... WA is essentially Ceded Territory. It will collapse under it's own Communist weight.