ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

‘I think it was sort of a trap’: Brian Heywood says a judge killed the income tax initiative lawsuit before his lawyers ever spoke

Brian Heywood says a Thurston County judge ruled on Let's Go Washington's I-645 ballot lawsuit using an unrelated case, leaving the campaign no hearing, no appeal.

THURSTON COUNTRY JUDGE...

A Thurston County judge upheld the state's ballot disclosure for Initiative 645 on Friday, canceling a separate hearing on the Let's Go Washington lawsuit before the campaign's attorneys could argue. (TVW)

(TVW)

A Thurston County judge codified the state’s ballot warning about Washington’s income tax repeal into place on Friday without ever hearing from the campaign that sued over it. And now the leader of the movement to repeal the income tax is calling out the process.

Superior Court Judge Chris Lanese ruled from the bench in a case brought by Olympia open government activist Arthur West, a private citizen with no connection to Initiative 645 or Let’s Go Washington. The campaign’s own lawsuit was canceled once Lanese issued his ruling.

The disclosure now headed to November ballots tells voters that I-645 would decrease funding for public K-12 education, higher education and human services, primarily healthcare. The claim falls apart against the text of the tax it repeals, which does not collect a dollar until 2029. Let’s Go Washington founder Brian Heywood had promised a court fight over that wording weeks before Attorney General Nick Brown’s office wrote it.

He never got the fight by design.

‘I think it was sort of a trap’

Two challenges to the ballot disclosure were on the Thurston County docket Friday, and they were not asking for the same thing.

Arthur West is a longtime Olympia open government activist who files his own lawsuits without an attorney. He has no role in Initiative 645, no connection to Let’s Go Washington, and no stake in how the sentence on the ballot is worded. His case went after the 2022 law that created public investment impact disclosures in the first place, arguing the statements are politically charged propaganda and an unconstitutional intrusion on the people’s initiative power. He wanted the entire mechanism struck down.

ADVERTISEMENT

Let’s Go Washington was asking for something much narrower and far more useful to the campaign. It accepted that the state gets its sentence and asked a judge to rewrite it, offering language reflecting that repealing the tax would leave more money available in the state budget running through June 30, 2027. That case was scheduled before Judge John Skinder later the same day, and the campaign’s attorneys were ready to argue it.

Taking advantage of a non-lawyer

West went first, at the morning hearing. Heywood says Lanese asked the pro se litigant a question that had nothing to do with the constitutional claim West had actually brought.

“He goes in early in the morning, and I really believe that the judge took advantage of the non-lawyer status of Arthur West,” Heywood told listeners of The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. He recounted the exchange this way. “He said, ‘Hey, are you here to challenge the statement that goes on the ballot as well?’ And then he sort of throws out this, ‘If you do, then I’ll just make a ruling here and now.'”

ADVERTISEMENT

West said yes. That answer put the wording question in front of Lanese, and Lanese answered it, holding that the disclosure written by Attorney General Nick Brown’s office is appropriately neutral. Once that ruling existed, there was nothing left for Skinder to decide, and the afternoon hearing was canceled.

“Arthur West said ‘yes,’ and I think it was sort of a trap, and then the judge was like, ‘Well, okay, since he said yes, I have to rule on this,’ and when he did that by ruling on it with this unrelated case, he ruled on our case and preempted our judges from even hearing the case, and therefore preempted us from even presenting our case. It’s just mind blowing. I went through the cycles of grief about 20 times in about two minutes,” Heywood said.

‘It feels really like we got railroaded’

Heywood watched the tape afterward and says the judge argued the opposition’s case from the bench instead of confining himself to the neutrality question in front of him.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I talked to some other lawyers, and they said this judge should have said, ‘Oh, look, there’s some other cases on this later today. I’m not going to rule on it.’ But he didn’t do that,” Heywood noted.

He continued, “instead he went on to say that the initiative itself was not neutral, and that somebody has to tell the voters, and someone has to stop this regressive spiral down. It’s sort of the words that he used.”

“I think he’s an activist judge,” Heywood said, adding, “It feels really like we got railroaded.”

No hearing, no appeal, and a Friday deadline

Washington law routes ballot title and disclosure challenges exclusively through Thurston County and prohibits appeals. West can appeal because his case attacked the statute. Let’s Go Washington cannot.

“The process in Washington was designed this way, and there’s a flaw in the system. Whether it’s a flaw or design, I don’t know,” Heywood said. The remaining option is asking the state Supreme Court to take it, with county election offices facing an Aug. 21 deadline to finalize ballots.

ADVERTISEMENT

The campaign is weighing a different response entirely. “But what we can do, and we’re looking into, is file ethics charges against this judge,” Heywood said.

Then there is the calendar. Heywood, who has spent more than $10 million fighting Olympia’s tax agenda, pointed out that the hearing was scheduled for the last day anything could still be changed before ballots go to print.

“The hearing was scheduled not early, not soon, not like ‘oh hey this is really something important.’ They did it on the very last day, so there’s no timing left to change it on the ballot without disrupting something else,” he said. “I’m sure that was just a complete coincidence.”

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

3 Comments

J
Jeff E 3 months ago

Of course we got railroaded... he did what a good comrade should always do. Once they have total control, there is only one way to remedy the situation.

S
Sean S 3 months ago

the DOJ and FBI need to get involved, this type of judicial slap down activism has become all too common in blue states that are ruled by one party and owns governorship, legislature and judiciary.

L
Lori D. Stach 3 months ago

So what happens now?
Filing charges against an activist judge is great, however, it sounds like the wording on the ballot is going to stay, even though it's a big fat bald faced Lie!!
My thought, is full blown media airwaves (radio and TV) stating the truth!
Including the incident with the activist judge!!
😤😡😠🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️