Mark Weaver: Separation of powers is another way of saying ‘stay in your lane!’
President Trump has been criticized for removing U.S. attorney Roger Rogoff, but former deputy attorney general of Ohio Mark Weaver says he was within his right.
The separation of powers is a critical component of our constitutional order (Getty Images)
(Getty Images)
In 1920, Portland postmaster Frank Myers refused to accept that President Woodrow Wilson had fired him. He sued and his case earned a place in constitutional law casebooks. William Howard Taft, the only man ever to head two branches of our government (president and chief justice), wrote the Supreme Court opinion that recognized that the power to remove executive officers like Myers belongs to the president alone.
That principle is not a dusty relic. Just last month, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that executive officials generally must remain subject to presidential control and removal. A federal prosecutor – an official who brings the government’s criminal power to bear against its citizens – also exists within the president’s domain.
While it’s true the Supreme Court previously approved the judicial appointment of an independent counsel, that prosecutor had limited jurisdiction and a defined assignment expressly meant to be outside the control of the president. It’s an exception to the broader rule.
Judges need to stay in their lane
A century after Taft’s opinion, 175 miles up the Pacific coast, this rule was ignored.
That’s because, last week, the federal judges of the Western District of Washington appointed Roger Rogoff as U.S. attorney in Seattle. He took the oath and, less than an hour later — while still waiting in the lobby of his new office — he received an email. The president had removed him. He never even had time to try out the big leather chair.
The president was right, and the judges were wrong. Don’t take my word for it. Read the Constitution. I’ve spent most of my career reading and applying it.
I was the Deputy Attorney General in Ohio and, before that, spokesman for the U.S. Department of Justice. I’ve also advised judges and state supreme court justices on ethics. Here’s one of the first lessons I learned: stay in your lane, even when the other lane is a mess. A U.S. attorney is the president’s chosen prosecutor in his district, and federal prosecution authority is on loan from Article II.
Trump was within his power to remove Rogoff
Give the judges their due. Rogoff is well qualified. The judges acted under a real federal statute, which permits a district court to fill a seat when a 120-day interim appointment expires without a Senate-confirmed nominee. While the Supreme Court hasn’t weighed in, two federal circuits have upheld that arrangement.
Those courts relied on the Appointments Clause, which permits Congress to vest the appointment of “inferior Officers” in “the Courts of Law.” But that exception is not a blank check. A U.S. attorney is not a clerk serving the court. He is the district’s chief federal prosecutor, exercising the sovereign power to litigate cases before the very judges who selected him.
Even if those courts are right about the appointment, that does not make the court’s choice untouchable. The same federal code says that “each United States attorney is subject to removal by the President.” Congress may have given judges a temporary role in filling the vacancy, but it did not give them the final word.
The president’s Article II power is clear
The Constitution recognizes three sources of federal power, and only three. Article I empowers Congress alone to write the laws. Article III entrusts judges alone to decide the cases. And Article II vests “the executive Power,” every ounce of it, in one elected officer, commanding him to take care that the laws be faithfully executed. Today, that president is Donald Trump. You – or federal judges – can be gleeful or grumpy about that fact, but it’s still reality.
Justice Antonin Scalia, writing from his Article III perch, in a famous dissent, read Article II to mean “not some of the executive power, but all of the executive power.” Prosecution is that power in its most concentrated form. This was true before Donald Trump took office. It will be true long after he leaves.
Executive power prevents a rogue judiciary
Judges picking prosecutors may rightly cause defendants to wonder whether the government’s lawyer carries the special confidence of the judges who picked him. The arrangement looks like the umpire filling out the visiting team’s lineup card. The public deserves a prosecutor selected and supervised by executive officials who ultimately answer to a president the voters can fire. Short of impeachment, nobody can fire a life-tenured federal judge.
When the Supreme Court takes this up, the answer will be the one Taft gave a century ago: the president’s officers serve the president — and only the president can show them the door.
Mark Weaver is a former deputy attorney general of Ohio and a former spokesman for the U.S. Department of Justice. He is the author of the new children’s book “God Bless America, 250 Years Strong.” On X: @MarkRWeaver
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
0 Comments