Judge says Washington governors, not voters, pick the courts. That’s not the way it should be
Washington Supreme Court candidate Dave Larson says governors, not voters, choose most state judges, and he has a plan to give the public a real say.
Judge Dave Larson is running for the Washington State Supreme Court on a pledge to change how the state fills judicial vacancies. (Photo courtesy of Judge Dave Larson Website)
(Photo courtesy of Judge Dave Larson Website)
Judge Dave Larson says Washington voters have almost no say in who sits on their courts, and he wants to overhaul how the state fills its most powerful judicial seats.
Larson, a former Federal Way Municipal Court judge now running for the Washington State Supreme Court, argues that the practice of justices retiring mid-term so a governor can appoint a replacement has cut voters out of the process. Six of the nine current justices first reached the bench through appointment rather than election, a pattern that accelerated under former Gov. Jay Inslee and has continued under Gov. Bob Ferguson.
Five of those nine seats are on the November ballot, and the reshaped court is expected to weigh a challenge to Washington’s new tax on high earners.
An appointment system without a check
Larson said the state constitution requires judges to be elected, yet the appointment route has become the norm.
“I’m not sure why people wouldn’t see the problem that the people don’t have a say in who their judges are when the constitution requires judges to be elected,” Larson told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.
He pointed to figures from a 2024 Seattle Times op-ed, noting that 172 of the state’s 207 judges had been appointed by Inslee, with fewer than 30 contested elections statewide. In his own 2024 Supreme Court race, Larson said roughly 700,000 fewer people voted for the high court than for governor, a gap he blames on voters not knowing how to evaluate judicial candidates.
“It would be wrong if it was a Republican, wrong if it’s a Democrat,” he said, arguing the trouble starts when a governor installs someone with a demonstrated loyalty to the person who appointed them. He noted appointments that included a former gubernatorial staffer and a longtime campaign donor from the governor’s old law firm, neither of whom had ever served as a judge.
A commission to rate the candidates
Larson has written a proposed statute that would create a Judicial Elections Commission, a bipartisan panel that would score candidates and hand the governor a short list. He compared it to the civil service “rule of three” that governments have used for decades to limit cronyism, with the governor required to pick from the top three rated contenders.
Asked how anyone measures judicial fitness, Larson said trial and litigation experience should count for a Supreme Court seat, along with a willingness to set aside personal views.
“It’s our ability to overcome our opinions and decide things based on the law, the Constitution,” he said.
He wants the same rating system pushed out to voters so they can weigh candidates the way the commission would.
Why voters should care
“Do you trust that the court system is going to make decisions based on the law and the Constitution, or do you think they’re going to make it based on personal ideology?” he asked, adding that most people no longer trust the courts even though many judges are fair.
He has drawn an unusual coalition of Democrats, Republicans, and independents, which he attributes to a hunger for judges who rule the same way no matter who backs them.
“I think what people see is that I’m going to be that judge, that regardless of the outcome, they’re going to trust it came from the right place for the right reason, regardless of politics, regardless of anything else,” Larson said.
The issue, he noted, is not new to his campaign.
“I rang the alarm bell 10 years ago on this, and it’s finally, I think, starting to get some traction,” he said.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
3 Comments
What a corrupt state!
Yes, it would be nice if voters had a say, but it’s clear that over the years we don’t. Unfortunately, I don’t see anything changing.
These aren't your granddad's Democrats.