Judge Dave Stevens says Washington Supreme Court justices rule by ideology, not the constitution
Mason County Judge Dave Stevens, running for WA Supreme Court Position 3, says the court's progressive majority rules by ideology. Primary ballots mail Friday.
Mason County Superior Court Judge Dave Stevens is running for Position 3 on the Washington State Supreme Court, arguing the current bench decides cases based on preferred outcomes instead of the state constitution. Primary ballots mail Friday ahead of the August 4 primary. (Judge David Stevens website)
(Judge David Stevens website)
Mason County Superior Court Judge Dave Stevens is running for the open Position 3 seat on the Washington State Supreme Court, and he says the race comes down to one question. Do judges follow the state constitution, or do they rule based on the outcomes they prefer? He argues the current court has already given its answer.
The stakes are unusually high. Five of the court’s nine seats are on the ballot this year, a rare opportunity to reshape a bench dominated by justices appointed by former Gov. Jay Inslee and Gov. Bob Ferguson. Primary ballots mail Friday ahead of the August 4 primary, where the top two candidates in each race advance to November.
Stevens says voters are finally catching on to what the court has been doing, and the contrast with his opponents makes the choice unusually clear.
A philosophical divide with Judge Mike Diaz
Stevens is running against King County Superior Court Judge Jaime Hawk and Court of Appeals Judge Mike Diaz, who has described his judicial philosophy as legal pragmatism. Stevens argues that approach is the root of the court’s problems.
“So a judge should take into consideration the practical consequences and real world usefulness, and so they don’t believe in absolute truths. They look at the effects,” Stevens explained on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM, describing the pragmatist view. “See, my philosophy is you follow the state constitution, and you don’t take into consideration the practical consequences.”
He argues that outcome-driven judging puts justices in a role the constitution never gave them.
“When you start determining cases based on what you think the consequences are, then you’re substituting yourself for the people who wrote the Constitution, for the legislature that wrote the laws,” Stevens said.
Blake, gun rights, and the receipts
Stevens pointed to the court’s 2021 Blake decision, which struck down the state’s felony drug possession law, as proof the court’s version of pragmatism only runs one direction.
“They wouldn’t see the practical consequences of open drug use, more rampant crime, the fact that everything has to be behind glass and locked up in stores in Seattle, as they wouldn’t even consider those practical consequences,” he said. “What they would look at is they felt that certain minorities were being prosecuted too much. They would look at that practical consequence and see that’s the real problem.”
He also cited a recent state ruling stripping gun rights from people with two DUI misdemeanors, a decision he noted was contradicted by the U.S. Supreme Court just days later in a case involving casual marijuana use.
“See, they believe that they can take into consideration the consequences, and then they find the studies that support it, and they pursue their ideological agendas because they don’t like gun rights,” Stevens argued.
“So this is a court because it’s staffed by progressives. Progressives that were appointed by Inslee and Ferguson, where they have an ideological agenda, and they’re going to figure out ways to pursue that ideological agenda, and that’s the whole problem,” he added.
Ballots mail Friday
The court’s makeup comes with real consequences this cycle. The justices unanimously blocked a referendum on the state’s new income tax in May, and a constitutional challenge to that tax is expected to reach the same bench. Former Attorney General Rob McKenna predicts unprecedented spending and attention on these races for exactly that reason.
Stevens is not the only challenger looking to change the court’s direction. Judge Dave Larson is running for Position 5 after coming within a fraction of a point of winning a seat in 2024. With ballots arriving in mailboxes as early as this weekend, voters should not wait to return them.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
0 Comments