ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Supreme Court upholds trans sports bans. Here’s what it means for Washington state

The Supreme Court ruled states can bar biological males from girls' sports, upholding Idaho and West Virginia laws as Washington voters weigh IL26-638.

supreme court...

The U.S. Supreme Court sided with Idaho and West Virginia in state laws banning transgender athletes from playing against biological girls or boys. (Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)

(Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)

The U.S. Supreme Court delivered a major win to supporters of Washington’s girls’ sports initiative on Tuesday, ruling 6-3 that states have the authority to keep biological males out of female athletics.

The decision in a pair of cases out of Idaho and West Virginia upheld state laws requiring student athletes to compete according to their biological sex rather than their gender identity. The ruling reverses lower court decisions that had blocked the bans and effectively validates similar laws in more than two dozen states, including Idaho’s first-in-the-nation Fairness in Women’s Sports Act.

For Washington, the decision comes as voters will decide on Initiative IL26-638 this November, a measure that would reserve girls’ sports for biological females.

Supreme Court sides with Idaho and West Virginia

The court ruled in West Virginia v. B.P.J. and Little v. Hecox, two cases brought by transgender athletes who sued to compete on girls’ and women’s teams. Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote the majority opinion.

“Consistent with Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause, we hold that the States may maintain women’s and girls’ sports for biological females. They may determine eligibility for women’s and girls’ sports based on biological sex,” Kavanaugh wrote.

The decision marks the first time the high court has weighed in on the national fight over transgender athletes in school sports. Idaho was the first state to pass such a law, and its statute was one of the two directly upheld. This decision was expected given how oral arguments ensued.

ADVERTISEMENT

What it means for Washington’s ballot fight

Washington still allows athletes to compete consistent with their gender identity, a policy the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association(WIAA) has defended even as several school districts pushed back. The Supreme Court’s decision does not change the policy in Washington state.

That could change in November. Let’s Go Washington, the group founded by Brian Heywood, collected more than 445,000 signatures to put IL26-638 on the ballot. The measure would require students competing in girls’ sports to verify they are biologically female through a routine physical exam.

Supporters wasted no time tying the ruling to the campaign. Ahnaleigh Wilson, a high school track athlete from East Wenatchee who traveled to Washington, D.C. for a rally to protect girls’ sports, welcomed the outcome in a statement released by Let’s Go Washington.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Today’s Supreme Court decision is such a big win for female athletes in Washington and across the country. As a female student-athlete who has competed against boys in girls’ sports, this issue has been deeply personal to me,” Wilson said.

Let’s Go Washington weighs in

Let’s Go Washington spokesperson Hallie Herzberg framed the decision as a direct rebuke to state leaders who have defended the current policy.

“This case is a victory for girls across the country, but specifically in Washington State. We know that girls deserve equal protection under the law and SCOTUS just affirmed that they know that too,” Herzberg said. “This case gives states the authority to stand up for girls, something Chris Reykdal, Jamie Pedersen, Laurie Jinkins, and Bob Ferguson have been too cowardly to do. Voting yes on 638 will protect girls’ sports and confirm once and for all that girls deserve safe and fair access to their sports, spaces, and opportunities.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Kavanaugh noted the court was not deciding whether states may go the other way and allow biological males to compete as transgender athletes, a question still working through lower courts.

SCOTUS will weigh in on separate Washington law

The sports ruling is not the only Washington gender battle now before the justices.

The Supreme Court has also agreed to hear International Partners for Ethical Care v. Ferguson, a challenge to three state laws that let minors as young as 13 access gender treatments without parental consent and require shelters to notify the state, not parents, when a runaway child seeks that care.

A group of Washington parents says the laws replaced them with the state, and the court will first decide whether they even have standing to sue.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

2 Comments

S
Shawn m 5 months ago

For the time being, it looks like SCOTUS wants to have its cake and eat it too. Red state, you want no biological boys near girls? You Got It. Blue state, want to crush biological girls with impunity? You Got That, Too.

F
Frank Coluccio 5 months ago

This is a WIN for Women's/Girl's sports!!!
XX vs XX, XY vs. XY ONLY