ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Supreme Court agrees to hear Washington case on parental rights and gender care for minors

The Supreme Court will hear International Partners for Ethical Care v. Ferguson, a challenge to Washington laws on minor gender care and parental notice.

Exterior of the U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C., where justices will hear Washingto...

The U.S. Supreme Court will review three Washington laws that let runaway minors access gender care while limiting parental notice and reunification. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)

(Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)

The United States Supreme Court has agreed to decide whether a group of Washington parents has standing to challenge a series of state laws that let minors access gender transition procedures without parental consent. The case, International Partners for Ethical Care v. Ferguson, reaches the high court after the Ninth Circuit ruled the parents could not sue because their alleged injuries were self-imposed. A win for the parents would clear the way for a direct constitutional fight over the laws themselves.

The nation’s high court will review three different Washington state laws in International Partners for Ethical Care v. Ferguson. First, they will review a law that allows minors who are at least 13 years old to receive “outpatient treatment” without parental consent. The court will also look at a Washington law that mandates overnight shelters to notify the state rather than parents if a child flees their home to access “protected” health care such as “gender-affirming care.” The third law in question allows minors to stay in shelters for up to 90 days.

How Washington’s shelter law sidelines parents

When a child runs away from home, state law requires a shelter to notify parents within 72 hours. The shelter must also provide the child’s location, their physical and emotional condition, and the reason the child contacted the shelter. However, state law includes exceptions for “compelling reasons” to not notify parents such as “abuse or neglect.”

ADVERTISEMENT

In 2023, Democrats in Olympia passed legislation expanding the definition of “compelling reasons” to include “gender-affirming care.” Proponents of the bill argue that these procedures will help ameliorate anxiety, depression, and suicidality among people with gender dysphoria. Studies like a peer-reviewed report released by HHS last year or the Cass Review out of the United Kingdom show the evidence for this is scant though, and that these procedures pose long-term risks to children.

Critics of the bill also noted that this is effectively tantamount to state-sanctioned kidnapping. A group of parents represented by International Partners for Ethical Care sued Washington for passing “laws that deliberately target certain parents by supplanting them with the state in the context of gender-confused runaway minors.”

SCOTUS has a recent record of siding with parents

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals declined to hear the case last summer, ruling that the parents lacked standing.

ADVERTISEMENT

“In the legislature’s view, a child suffering from gender dysphoria must be ‘protected’ from parents who do not seek ‘gender-affirming treatment’ for their child and do not ‘affirm the child’s gender identity,” wrote Trump-appointed Judge Eric Tung in his dissenting opinion. Tung added that the Washington law “thus places parents who wish to raise their child in accordance with the child’s biological sex in the same category as parents who are abusive or neglectful.”

There is reason for optimism for Washington parents given the Supreme Court’s recent history in parental rights cases. In last year’s Mahmoud v. Taylor, it ruled that Maryland public schools must let parents opt their children out of lessons involving LGBTQ+ themes. The court also upheld an injunction of a California law earlier this year that required educators to hide a student’s gender transition from their parents in Mirabelli v. Bonta.

ADVERTISEMENT

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jackson Meyer Producer, The Jason Rantz Show

Born and raised in Issaquah, Jackson is a lifelong Washingtonian. He is an avid sports fan, particularly of baseball, which he played at the varsity level in High School. He worked at the Seattle-based conservative think tank Discovery Institute for… Read more

Comments

0 Comments