Seattle's JumpStart Tax KILLED 30,000 Downtown Jobs
Seattle's JumpStart payroll tax was sold as the responsible way to make Amazon and a handful of tech giants pay their fair share. Five years in, a new Downtown Seattle Association report ties it to roughly 30,000 lost downtown jobs and a 48% collapse in the taxable value of office buildings.
While Seattle's core bled jobs and watched commercial property values crater, Bellevue did the opposite. With no comparable employer tax, Bellevue added jobs and saw commercial values climb 7% over the same five-year stretch. Amazon has built its Bellevue workforce to around 15,000 people as part of what it now calls a regional headquarters, and DSA President Jon Scholes says the group warned the city this would happen and got brushed off. Mayor Katie Wilson, who helped design the tax before her election, still calls it a success.
This is the Seattle JumpStart payroll tax story the local media keeps soft-pedaling: a Seattle downtown job loss problem, the worst office vacancy rate in the nation, the Amazon Bellevue expansion, and a Washington state business tax fight that keeps pushing employers east. About 70% of JumpStart collections come from just 10 companies, leaving the whole thing exposed every time one of them trims its Seattle headcount.