ADVERTISEMENT
October 27th, 2026

Seattle Homeless Rejected 3 in 4 Shelter Offers. DSA Calls It a MYTH.

Jon Scholes says service-resistant homeless people in Seattle are a myth. The pilot program he used to prove it had 10 people out of 80 say no to shelter. Anyone who's walked Third Avenue could have told him.

The Downtown Seattle Association president made the claim October 21 as Mayor Katie Wilson announced she's taking the Pioneer Square "Streets to Housing" pilot citywide. Scholes rattled off his wins: 85 people moved out of a park, 40 off Third Avenue, 70 brought inside in Pioneer Square this summer. Then he said this: "This idea that we have a lot of service-resistant people in our city, I just think is a myth, and it's not a thing." Here's the problem. That Pioneer Square number came from a list of 80. Seventy accepted. Ten didn't, inside the very program he held up as evidence. Citywide, roughly three-quarters of 2024 shelter offers were turned down. And Denver, the city Wilson keeps pointing to, had almost 500 more sworn officers than Seattle last year.

Andrea Suarez of We Heart Seattle was in the room, and she joined The Jason Rantz Show to explain what Scholes left out. Her list of the "services" that actually get people off the street: jail, rehab, Fairfax, tickets home, serving warrants. She cornered him after the press conference and asked why law enforcement never came up once. Denver and Houston have fully staffed police forces that enforce camping bans. Seattle has a plan built entirely on Housing First, the same model Pramila Jayapal wants to take national. Suarez's verdict on the people running it: "Success for them is housing without requirement, and that has failed."

After a decade and billions of dollars, Seattle's homelessness establishment still won't make treatment a requirement. Calling the problem a myth won't clear a single tent.

Jason Rantz and Andrea Suarez break down Jon Scholes and the Downtown Seattle Association, Katie Wilson's Streets to Housing expansion, Housing First, Seattle homelessness, service-resistant homeless, fentanyl addiction on Third Avenue, Pioneer Square, the Denver model, Seattle Police staffing, We Heart Seattle, and Pramila Jayapal's national housing push.

Jason Rantz

Homelessness