Seattle Doctor Claims Telling a Boy From a Girl Is a Medical MYSTERY
A Seattle doctor wants you to believe telling a boy from a girl is too complex for a sports physical, and the Seattle Times gave her top billing days before voters decide I-638. It reads less like health reporting and more like a No on I-638 mailer.
The Seattle Times story leans on Dr. Glenna Martin, a family physician who practices gender affirming medicine and opposes the initiative. She claimed there is no consistent research showing trans girls hold an athletic edge over girls, and the paper printed it without a single sports scientist to push back. So Jason Rantz does it for them. A Sports Medicine review by Emma Hilton and Tommy Lundberg found the male performance gap reaches 10 to 50 percent depending on the sport, and a year of testosterone suppression cuts muscle mass and strength by only about 5 percent. A British Journal of Sports Medicine study of 46 trans women in the Air Force found they still ran the 1.5-mile test 12 percent faster than female peers two years into hormone therapy. In 2017, 285 boys under 18 beat the fastest 400-meter time posted by any woman on the planet. Locally, UW women's soccer lost a scrimmage to under-14 boys. Martin also vowed to resist a genital exam that I-638 never requires: "I would probably cross that part off and say, 'this is not medically indicated.'" And count the voices in the article. Three physicians, all against the initiative, all authors of op-eds opposing it, none of it disclosed by the reporter. Washington voters don't need a medical degree to know a boy from a girl. Ballots are due by 8 p.m. Tuesday.
Jason Rantz breaks down the Seattle Times I-638 coverage, Dr. Glenna Martin, Initiative 638, boys in girls' sports in Washington, male athletic advantage research, the Hilton and Lundberg study, Let's Go Washington, Seattle Times media bias, and the 2026 Washington ballot.