ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

Bellevue Chamber CEO warns WA budget is ‘riding the knife’ with no room to fall

Bellevue Chamber CEO Joe Fain warns Washington's $113.8M revenue shortfall leaves the state with almost no cushion before the June forecast forces painful cuts or a tax hike.

Washington State Capitol building in Olympia, site of Democrats' passage of SB 6346, the 9.9% milli...

The Washington State Capitol in Olympia, where Democrats wasted millions in taxpayer dollars yet again. (Photo by David Ryder/Getty Images)

(Photo by David Ryder/Getty Images)

Washington’s state budget is running out of room fast, and Bellevue Chamber CEO Joe Fain says the latest collections data make that difficult to dismiss. March General Fund-State collections came in $71.2 million below forecast, pushing the two-month shortfall to $113.8 million against a projected ending balance of just $231 million, roughly three-tenths of one percent of total spending.

Fain, a former Washington State senator who served on the Senate Ways and Means Committee, published a detailed analysis of the numbers this week in his newsletter “From the Bellevue Chamber CEO.” He argued state lawmakers constructed a budget with no meaningful cushion, and that the current data shows exactly what happens when optimistic revenue assumptions run into a deteriorating economy.

“That is what it means to ride the knife: leaving such a thin balance, such small reserves, and such optimistic assumptions that even a modest miss can threaten balance before the biennium is over,” Fain wrote.

A spending problem, not a revenue problem

The shortfall didn’t happen because Washington’s tax revenue collapsed. Revenue Act collections were up 6.5 percent from a year earlier, with the 12-month average showing growth just under 6 percent, he noted. That context makes the situation worse, not better. The state is missing its own projections even as overall revenue grows.

“The problem is not that revenues disappeared,” Fain argued. “The problem is that lawmakers built a budget that assumes very little can go wrong at a time when things are going wrong left and right.”

Washington’s unemployment rate has risen to 5.1 percent, above the national average, and Seattle metro unemployment has climbed 30 to 50 percent over the past year alone. Tech layoffs continue to drag on the regional economy as employers pull back sharply on white-collar and software hiring. All of this is playing out after Democrats passed $9.4 billion in new taxes in 2025 and returned in 2026 with billions more, including a new 9.9 percent income tax on high-income households that won’t take effect until 2028.

ADVERTISEMENT

What the June forecast could mean

The March shortfall accelerated sharply. It came in 67 percent larger than February’s miss, and the cumulative hole has grown to $113.8 million with only $231 million in projected ending balance standing between the state and a technical deficit. Fain says the window to avoid a crisis is narrowing.

“If collections do not improve, the June forecast will erase the small ending balance and push the budget out of balance,” he cautioned. “At that point, the state is left with only unattractive choices: across-the-board cuts by the Governor, or a special session of the legislature to rewrite the budget or raise additional taxes.”

The weakness isn’t confined to the major Revenue Act taxes. Non-Revenue Act streams also missed projections, with property tax, liquor, cigarette, and miscellaneous Department of Revenue revenue all coming in below forecast for the period. March collections totaled $2.065 billion against a forecast of $2.137 billion. The only meaningful bright spots were real estate excise tax receipts, up 15 percent, and court fees and fines, up 19.8 percent.

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

4 Comments

W
Waldo62 . 7 months ago

Odd comment “The only meaningful bright spots were real estate excise tax receipts, up 15 percent, and court fees and fines, up 19.8 percent.” Meaningful only in the eyes of the parasitic political class.

J
Jake Morningwood 7 months ago

This legislature will only raise taxes in response. Their only challenge is how to blame it on Trump. Meanwhile they will continue to spend millions on cosmetic surgery for transgender inmates.

P
Pablo Abo 7 months ago

It annoys me when politicians talk about "revenues" as if they are selling some valuable goods and services.
These are TAX DOLLARS taken from us!