ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Seattle city council president admits to having a ‘black budget’, calls black voters a ‘political party,’ and then runs away from questions

Seattle Council President Joy Hollingsworth admitted to running a race-based 'black budget' — then canceled her Rantz interview without explanation.

Seattle City Council President Joy Hollingsworth speaks at the State of Africatown 2026 conference;...

Seattle City Council President Joy Hollingsworth addresses the State of Africatown 2026 conference, where she described maintaining a separate "black budget" alongside her District 3 city budget. (Seattle Channel)

(Seattle Channel)

Seattle City Council President Joy Hollingsworth stood in front of a crowd at the State of Africatown 2026 conference in February and announced she runs two budgets. One, she said, is specifically for black Seattleites. And it’s intended to create what she calls a new “political party.”

“I have my district three budget, and then I have my ‘black budget,'” Hollingsworth said at the conference. “So I got to budget every time I go to councilmember Dan Strauss, every year I have a district three budget and then a black budget.”

The president of the Seattle City Council, who represents all of District 3, openly described operating what amounts to a parallel budgeting process sorted by race. Naturally, there are reasonable questions.

Hollingsworth initially responded to written questions by saying she’d come on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM, and the interview was scheduled for Tuesday May 5. She implied she had nothing to hide about the process or what’s in the so-called “black budget.” Then, she abruptly canceled without explanation, sending a note saying she’s looking forward to hearing the segment, though did not respond to a single question about her budget.

Her decision was not due to a scheduling conflict. It was political cowardice on display. It doesn’t take courage to sit down with someone who disagrees with you. But it does take a particular kind of cowardice to bail without even offering a reason.

ADVERTISEMENT

A budget sorted by race — and possibly illegal

At the Africatown conference, Hollingsworth delivered statistics she described as the reason a separate budgetary priority list for black Seattle residents was necessary. The median household income for black families in Seattle is $55,000, compared to $130,000 for white families. Black home ownership is down from 50% in 1970 to 28% today. These are legitimate disparities, and a council member who wants to address them deserves credit for at least naming them out loud.

But the framework she’s built around those numbers is a different matter entirely. And she’s not interested in talking about why.

If the “black budget” is a literal, formal allocation of city funds designated by race, it almost certainly runs into the same constitutional wall that race-based reparations programs in Washington state have already hit. The state constitution’s guarantee of equal protection does not recognize race as a valid basis for distributing public resources to the detriment of others. A council member cannot simply carve out a separate discretionary pot of government money organized around the skin color of intended recipients and expect that to be legally uncontested.

ADVERTISEMENT

If the “black budget” is instead a political brand Hollingsworth applies to her advocacy priorities when she lobbies Budget Chair Dan Strauss each year, then it is something else: a calculated and unserious political performance for a specific constituency. That’s still a problem, but a different one. She wouldn’t be the only politician pandering to a constituency for votes.

But we’d rightly call out a “white budget.” And it’s worth asking why Hollingsworth doesn’t appear eager to offer other constituencies their own budget. Perhaps she doesn’t care enough about Asians or Latinos?

Councilmember Dan Strauss did not respond to a request for comment.

Who does Joy Hollingsworth actually represent in District 3?

District 3 includes Capitol Hill, the Central District, Madison Park, Leschi, and a handful of other Seattle neighborhoods. The residents there are not monolithic. They include renters and homeowners, small business owners and service workers, people of every background who elected Hollingsworth to represent their interests before the full council.

ADVERTISEMENT

But at the Africatown conference, she went further than budget advocacy, admitting to intentionally using taxpayer dollars to organize a new political party that’s race-exclusionary.

“There are political parties in Seattle, and I believe that if black people come together, we can be the most powerful political party in the city of Seattle,” she told the audience. “We have to coalesce our power. And so we set up. So this is what we did this year, and then we’re going to be able to advocate for next year.”

A sitting council president describing one racial group as a potential political party unto itself, and positioning herself as the vehicle for that coalition using tax dollars, is a clearcut declaration of who she sees as her real base. That should concern every non-black resident of District 3 who wonders whether their interests register the same way when Hollingsworth walks into Strauss’s office with her two budgets. She’s strongly implying that they don’t.

ADVERTISEMENT

More spending, no accountability: Seattle’s race-targeted grant failures

The “black budget” conversation also cannot be separated from what Seattle progressives have built over the past several years: a sprawling network of race-targeted grant programs and community investment funds that have operated with virtually no financial scrutiny.

A forensic investigation into KCRHA found $13 million in public funds unaccounted for and a $45 million cash deficit. It’s a homelessness agency that absorbed hundreds of millions in public dollars while the city’s homeless population grew. A separate King County audit of the Department of Community and Human Services found rampant fraud, altered invoices, contractors paid outside the scope of their agreements, and nearly half of all grant recipients flagged as high-risk. As MyNorthwest reported, Hollingsworth herself called it a “system failure” and said the city has been “good at funding and generating ideas but poor at tracking outcomes.” She’s right about that. What she hasn’t explained is why the answer is more targeted funding streams organized by race rather than better accountability for the billions already going out the door.

ADVERTISEMENT

The city knows how to spend money on community programs with a racial equity framing. What it hasn’t figured out is how to tell whether any of it is working. Hollingsworth’s answer to that seems to be a separate budget, a “Black Budget Day,” a black advisory council, and an expanded reparations study. None of those things require Hollingsworth to answer a question she can’t handle. Which is probably why she won’t.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

11 Comments

W
WP Taylor 7 months ago

I have no doubt that the "black budget" is intended to help enrich loyal supporters and campaigners, just as Medicaid, SNAP, and federal child care support enriched a few supporters. And like the Federal funding frauds, her "black budget" won't help the black community much, if at all.

C
Clockwork Wyrm 7 months ago

"The median household income for black families in Seattle is $55,000, compared to $130,000 for white families."

Median household income is a deceptive metric in Seattle. Statistically, the greatest determining factor of financial success is a college degree, BA or higher. The national average of folks with a BA or higher is only ~35% (~28% of so-called Black folks hold a BA or higher), but in Seattle that rate is 70% regardless of race. If we're creating separate budgets, the real metric of division should be education level, not race. As a point of evidence, so-called Asians out perform every other race, including so-called Whites, and the quintessential difference is that so-called Asians have higher graduation rates and lowest unemployment rates, but that gets conveniently ignored.

M
MarkinWA Justmark 7 months ago

Hundreds of millions into KCRHA is an understatement. They burned through $253 million in 2024 alone.

Also, Google AI says 7-8% of Seattle's District 3 is black. That is higher than WA's 6% average. So District 3 must have a very vocal minority, enough to elect the unapologetic racist CM.