ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

Former council president says Seattle’s biggest tax experiment may be driving away the jobs downtown desperately needs

Former Seattle City Council President Sara Nelson says a new DSA report supports long-standing concerns that Seattle's JumpStart payroll tax hurt competitiveness and jobs.

Sarah Nelson exits Seattle Council, emphasizing reforms and accountability. (Photo courtesy of Coun...

Sarah Nelson exits Seattle Council, emphasizing reforms and accountability. (Photo courtesy of Councilmember Sara Nelson)

(Photo courtesy of Councilmember Sara Nelson)

A new report from the Downtown Seattle Association is reigniting debate over Seattle’s controversial JumpStart payroll tax, with former Seattle City Council President Sara Nelson arguing the findings validate years of warnings from critics.

The report suggests Seattle has lost roughly 30,000 jobs and significant office activity to Bellevue as major employers expanded outside city limits. While supporters of the tax dispute the conclusion and point to broader post-pandemic workplace trends, Nelson says the findings reflect a predictable consequence of making Seattle less attractive to employers. And given that Bellevue is doing better than it has in the past, it’s hard to put the problems on COVID.

“Clearly, if we make Seattle less competitive as a place to start and grow a business and create jobs, then other jurisdictions will get those businesses. Clearly, that is pretty simple, I believe,” Nelson explained on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.

The JumpStart payroll tax was approved in 2020 and applies to highly compensated employees at large businesses. Supporters have credited the tax with generating hundreds of millions of dollars for affordable housing and other city priorities. Critics have long argued it would discourage investment and job growth within Seattle.

Nelson says concerns predated JumpStart’s approval

Nelson noted that opposition to Seattle’s efforts to target large employers existed before the current payroll tax was enacted.

“I remember building trades unions coming out against Council Member Shama Sawant’s Amazon tax ideas, because they were concerned also about what it would do to the Seattle economy,” Nelson said.

ADVERTISEMENT

The new Downtown Seattle Association analysis comes as city leaders continue grappling with downtown recovery challenges, including elevated office vacancy rates and sluggish return-to-office activity compared to neighboring cities.

Some progressive activists and tax supporters have argued that remote work trends, not local tax policy, are primarily responsible for Seattle’s economic challenges. Nelson acknowledged those arguments but contended the payroll tax has contributed to the problem.

“The supposed solution is actually the disease driving the problem,” she said.

According to Nelson, businesses are making rational decisions when evaluating where to grow.

“When we make Seattle less hospitable to business, they’ll go elsewhere. They’re rational actors, and so that is what is happening,” Nelson said. “What does that result in? Job flight, business flight, less tax revenue.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Debate continues over tax revenue and city spending

The discussion surrounding JumpStart has become increasingly tied to Seattle’s budget challenges. Supporters frequently point to the tax as a major revenue source that helps fund affordable housing and social programs. Nelson questioned whether the city has become too dependent on a single revenue stream.

“The payroll expense tax, it was the largest tax ever passed that did not go to the ballot in Seattle,” Nelson said. “It has blown past those projections every single year.” She added, “Before we had the payroll tax, we should not be depending on such a huge percentage of our revenue on one single tax.”

Nelson also raised concerns about how affordable housing dollars are being deployed, noting that city spending in the category has increased substantially since JumpStart was adopted.

“I am pro-results, not anti-tax,” Nelson said. “If we are paying more and more money and doing the same thing, that’s the typical definition of insanity.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Whether the Downtown Seattle Association report ultimately changes the political debate remains to be seen. However, the findings have given opponents of the payroll tax fresh ammunition as questions continue about Seattle’s economic competitiveness and downtown recovery.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

1 Comments

C
Candis Gauvin 5 months ago

🤣🤣🤣🤣 DUH!