ADVERTISEMENT

TAXES

House Democrats pass Washington’s first income tax as Republicans warn middle class will eventually pay the price

WA Democrats passed a 9.9% income tax Tuesday. Republicans call it unconstitutional and a threat to the middle class.

Washington House Democrats passed a 9.9% income tax Tuesday as Republicans called it unconstitution...

Washington House Democrats passed a 9.9% income tax Tuesday as Republicans called it unconstitutional, warned the middle class will eventually pay, and blasted the bill's referendum block. (TVW)

(TVW)

Washington House Democrats passed Senate Bill 6346 Tuesday night, creating the state’s first income tax and drawing immediate fire from Republicans who called the vote a constitutional overreach, a slap at voters, and a direct threat to the state’s economy.

The bill cleared the House 51-46 following a marathon 24-hour floor debate. It imposes a 9.9% tax on household income above $1 million, but critics flag several landmines buried in the fine print. The income threshold can be lowered by a simple majority vote of a future legislature. Married couples receive the same $1 million exemption as single filers, creating a clear marriage penalty. And the bill includes a “necessity clause” designed to block voters from pursuing a referendum.

After its passage, news spread that Starbucks founder Howard Schultz announced that he was moving to Florida.

Republicans blast income tax vote as a ‘betrayal’

House Republican Leader Drew Stokesbary (R-Auburn) unloaded on his colleagues across the aisle following the vote.

“This is a betrayal of the people of Washington and a direct attack on our state’s economic competitiveness,” Stokesbary said. “For generations, Washington’s lack of a state income tax has helped attract jobs, entrepreneurs and investment, all of which has led to growth and prosperity. Democrats just took a sledgehammer to that advantage.”

Stokesbary warned that assurances the tax will stay limited to millionaires are worthless, and he backed up the warning with statements from Democrats themselves.

“House Deputy Majority Leader Larry Springer was asked before session why the public should assume this tax wouldn’t eventually apply to them. His answer was simple: ‘You shouldn’t,'” Stokesbary said. He added that Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen had dismissed his own party’s prior vote to ban an income tax as a “pie crust promise, easily made, easily broken.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Constitutional questions hang over the bill

Republicans argue the bill is unconstitutional on its face. Washington courts have held for nearly a century that income qualifies as property under the state constitution, which requires property taxes to be applied uniformly. By targeting only income above a specific threshold, Republicans say the bill violates that uniformity requirement.

Rep. Stephanie Barnard (R-Pasco) said the constitutional problems are made worse by the bill’s effort to cut the public out of the process entirely.

“This legislation includes a ‘necessity clause’ specifically designed to deny people their right to a referendum,” Barnard said. “Washington voters have rejected an income tax ten times at the ballot box. Rather than respecting that history, the majority chose to block accountability.”

The bill also directly amends Initiative 2111, the voter-approved ban on income taxes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Democrats rejected every Republican alternative

House Republicans said they came to the floor with solutions. House Republican Caucus Chair Peter Abbarno (R-Centralia) said his caucus offered 53 amendments covering sales tax reductions, retirement income protections, elimination of the marriage penalty, and guardrails to prevent future expansion. Every proposal was voted down.

“Washington does not have a revenue problem,” Abbarno said. “The majority party has a spending problem.”

Stokesbary framed the vote as the predictable result of unchecked Democratic control in Olympia.

“One-party rule has made Washington one of the most expensive states in the country,” Stokesbary said. “Yet the only answer Democrats ever seem to have is another tax.”

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

2 Comments

D
Doug Spittler 8 months ago

What's that word for "lying to yourself"? It's what people who profess to believe this tax won't soon engulf the middle class are doing. And just to be clear, there will NEVER be enough money to satisfy politicians' lust for pandering to voters. If the tax was 99%, politicians would be scheming how to get the remaining 1%.

W
Waldo62 . 8 months ago

"ITE" = Illusory Truth Effect