ADVERTISEMENT

ECONOMY

‘I told you so’: Former Seattle city council president breaks down gig economy collapse

A former Seattle council president says PayUp hurt the workers it promised to help — and the next mandate will too.

A former Seattle City Council president is sounding the alarm on PayUp's failures and a new push to...

A former Seattle City Council president is sounding the alarm on PayUp's failures and a new push to cap rideshare drivers — warning history is about to repeat itself.

Seattle’s war on gig workers, waged in their name, keeps claiming new victims. Now, a former council member is declaring, “I hate to say it but I told you so.”

Former Seattle City Council President Sara Nelson broke her silence this week in a lengthy LinkedIn post, cataloguing the wreckage left behind by the city’s PayUp law and warning that a new push to cap rideshare drivers will produce the same results. Her account is a damning firsthand indictment of the progressive policy machine that steamrolled her reform efforts and left workers worse off.

PayUp’s body count

PayUp, which took effect two years ago, set a minimum pay standard for app-based delivery drivers equivalent to roughly $30 per hour. Nelson had flagged the demand problem before the law passed. When drivers showed up begging for relief in early 2024, she tried to fix it.

“Guaranteed minimum wage plus 35 cents per mile traveled plus tips,” she wrote, describing her proposed reform. In exchange, app-based companies like Uber Eats would have dropped the $5 service fee strangling order volume.

Working Washington, which she described as “the SEIU front organization that pushed for PayUp,” killed it.

“Working Washington… mounted such fierce and prolonged opposition to any modification whatsoever that I dropped my legislation. They’d already taken PayUp to other cities and weren’t about to let Seattle expose its flaws. The politics were just insurmountable,” she wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

The numbers that followed were brutal. An industry report quantified the damage she had warned about.

“Delivery orders had fallen 25%, driver earnings had dropped a minimum of 28%, and Seattle restaurants had lost $17.6 million in sales in the first 13 weeks of 2024,” she wrote.

The next mandate is already coming

Now the Teamsters-affiliated Drivers Union wants to cap the number of drivers on rideshare apps, citing environmental concerns and depressed wages. Nelson connected the dots directly to FareShare, a 2020 council measure that she said triggered a 40% fare increase and a 50% drop in rides compared to similar markets, according to Uber’s data.

“This is a classic ‘if you give a mouse a cookie’ moment,” she wrote. “Each fix breaks something new, and the answer is always another mandate.”

Her bottom line was unsparing.

“Here’s the deal: this sustained effort to regulate Seattle’s gig economy — with the ultimate goal of reclassifying contract workers as employees — has ended up hurting the very workers it’s aiming to help,” she concluded.

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

2 Comments

E
Evan Lattimore 8 months ago

Subversives like Kshama Sawant have the opposite of the Midas Touch: Everything they touch turns to garbage, which is likely their intent, with their unwitting followers duped by rhetoric. Shame that Seattle is filled with so many of those duped.

J
Jake Morningwood 8 months ago

We the sheeple love this progressive interference of capitalism. Then when things go south we just blame greedy corporations or millionaires or Trump. The lack of self awareness is only equalled by the hypocrisy on display.