Rantz: Washington Democrats don’t need to steal elections. They rig the system before you ever vote
Washington Democrats don't cheat at the ballot box. They rig I-645 before ballots print, from the state's ballot sentence to the courts and the press.
A new DHM Research poll shows state-required ballot language sharply cuts support for Initiative 645, the income tax repeal. (Let's Go Washington/Facebook)
(Let's Go Washington/Facebook)
Washington Democrats don’t need to cheat when your ballot gets counted. They rig the game long before it’s printed, and a new poll on the income tax shows exactly how well it works.
The Seattle Times reported Tuesday on a DHM Research survey of 800 Washington residents that split the sample in half. One group of 400 read a standard summary of Initiative 645, which repeals the new 9.9% income tax. The other group read the same summary plus a sentence the state requires on your ballot, falsely claiming repeal will cost K-12 schools, universities and healthcare. Without the government’s sentence, the race was 44% opposed and 40% in favor, with 16% undecided. With it, opposition jumped to 57% and support fell to 35%.
One state-written sentence moved the undecideds and turned a close race into a blowout. Democrats designed it to do that. Even the Seattle Times concedes Democrats added the requirement in 2022 to fight tax-cutting initiatives. And it’s only one gear in a machine built so conservatives and independents have to work five times as hard to win anything, only to watch the Legislature or the courts take it away.
A poll that proves the ballot is rigged
Start with who DHM polled. The firm describes its sample as Washington residents, not likely voters. And the no-disclosure split, 44% to 40% on 400 people, is inside a margin of error of roughly five points by standard polling math. Without the state’s thumb on the scale, the repeal is statistically tied.
The same poll found 46% oppose the income tax if it could eventually hit incomes of $100,000 or more, while only 41% would keep it. Voters don’t believe the “millionaires” label. They shouldn’t.
That skepticism is the same reason Representative Pramila Jayapal is now inventing a $300 billion tax break for the rich, a number 26 times larger than the state’s estimate. When the facts don’t sell the tax, Democrats sell fear. And when fear isn’t enough, they print it on the ballot. And not a single local media outlet, outside of Seattle Red, will say anything about the abject lie.
Voters already said no
Keep in mind that because Washington Democrats prevented a referendum, the income tax repeal would go through a more arduous initiative process that now requires people to vote yes in order to get rid of the income tax. As was the case with the capital gains tax, the fear from income tax opponents is that voters will be confused and vote no, thinking they’re voting on whether or not to accept the income tax.
Washington voters killed an income tax in 2010, rejecting Initiative 1098 by 64% to 36%. In 2024, the Legislature adopted Initiative 2111, a statutory ban on state and local income taxes. Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen, who voted for it, later dismissed that ban as a pie crust promise, easily made and easily broken.
“I wouldn’t take that super-seriously,” Pedersen told KUOW.
Then he wrote the income tax. Democrats swear it’s only about millionaires. Yet when Senator Chris Gildon offered an amendment voiding the tax unless the state constitution limited it to millionaires, Democrats rejected it. In the House, they voted down an amendment to send the tax to voters. They also voted down an amendment to strip the clause blocking a referendum, according to the Washington State Standard.
That clause declares the tax necessary to support state government, even though it won’t collect a dime until 2029. The attorney general’s office helped. Solicitor General Noah Purcell warned Pedersen in a December 2025 email that the draft lacked an emergency clause.
“Without one, someone could try to subject the bill to a referendum,” Purcell wrote.
A referendum needed 154,455 signatures. Blocking it forced opponents into an initiative requiring 308,911, double the work. Let’s Go Washington founder Brian Heywood asked the Supreme Court to force Secretary of State Steve Hobbs to process his referendum, and the justices sided with their friends and supporters in the Legislature, as they always do. His team gathered 511,408 signatures anyway.
The state writes an ad on your ballot
The disclosure that swung the DHM poll exists because Democrats created it. House Bill 1876 was sponsored in 2022 by Democratic Representatives including Mia Gregerson and Joe Fitzgibbon. It requires the attorney general to attach a public investment impact disclosure to any ballot measure that repeals or changes a tax. A year later, Democrats scrapped the tax advisory votes that voters created through Initiative 960. Then-Senator Patty Kuderer called those advisory votes anti-tax propaganda polluting the ballot. Pro-tax messaging on the ballot, however, is apparently transparency.
Attorney General Nick Brown’s office wrote the I-645 version.
“This measure would decrease funding for public K-12 education, higher education (including universities and community colleges), and human services (primarily healthcare),” the ballot will read.
The income tax funds none of those things today. It collects nothing until 2029, and repealing it cuts no existing program.
The statute doesn’t even ask what the measure does. According to a Washington Research Council analysis, the disclosure simply lists the three largest categories of general fund spending, and it isn’t based on the official fiscal impact statement. That statement says the direct spending reduction is mostly the cost of administering the tax. The biggest loser under repeal is a Department of Revenue bureaucracy that doesn’t exist yet.
The judges grade the state’s homework
Ballot title fights go to Thurston County Superior Court. Judge Chris Lanese upheld Brown’s wording in August. His ruling also scuttled Let’s Go Washington’s separate challenge, set for a different judge that same day, before its lawyers could even argue a word. From the bench, Lanese sounded like he was delivering a Democratic floor speech on budgets.
“Nobody wants to pay taxes,” Lanese complained.
Retired Justice Richard Sanders points out that in a related proceeding, Thurston County Superior Court Judge Anne Egeler found that language describing how general fund dollars will be spent in the future would be inaccurate and misleading. It didn’t matter.
At the Supreme Court, the challenge deadlocked 4-4. Justices Charles Johnson, Sheryl Gordon McCloud, Helen Whitener and Theo Angelis wanted the sentence off the ballot. Chief Justice Debra Stephens and Justices Steven González, Salvador Mungia and Colleen Melody kept it. Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis didn’t participate. The court never appointed a temporary justice to break the tie, so an unelected commissioner’s denial stood. It seemed like the 4-4 split was engineered so they can pretend that they weren’t engineering a political result.
Look at who held the line for the state. Melody spent a decade leading the civil rights division of the attorney general’s office. Bob Ferguson hired her there, and as governor he then put her on the court. The office that wrote the ballot sentence used to be her office.
A court built by appointment
Six of the nine current justices first reached the Supreme Court by appointment from a Democratic governor. Christine Gregoire picked Stephens and González. Jay Inslee picked Montoya-Lewis and Whitener. Ferguson picked Melody and Angelis.
The trick is timing. Justices are elected to six-year terms. But when one leaves mid-term, the governor names the replacement, who then faces voters as the incumbent. Justice Barbara Madsen, reelected five times, stepped down in April. Justice Mary Yu left at the end of 2025. Both left before their terms were up. Ferguson filled both seats with lawyers he’d worked alongside, and both now appear on the November ballot with the title of justice attached to their names. Those justices are corrupt partisans who brought shame to the Court. They don’t care. They were there to serve their ideology, not the law.
This is the same court that ruled in 2023 that the capital gains tax was an excise tax, not an income tax. They had to contort themselves into pretzels to get to that point. It’s also the court that decides whether your initiatives survive.
Win anyway, and they undo it
In 2024, the Legislature adopted Initiative 2081, the Parents’ Bill of Rights, with bipartisan votes after hundreds of thousands of residents signed for it. One year later, Democrats passed House Bill 1296 and gutted it.
Heywood, at the time, accused Democrats of logrolling by tacking two other bills onto HB 1296. So he collected signatures again for IL26-001, which re-enacts the law the Legislature already approved. Pedersen and House Speaker Laurie Jinkins refused to even hold hearings on it or on the girls’ sports initiative, sending both to the ballot.
Nearly 2 million voters passed Initiative 2066 in 2024 to protect natural gas access. This month, the Supreme Court tossed it 6-3, ruling it violated the single-subject rule. Courts used the same rule to kill the car tab measures I-695 in 2000 and I-976 in 2020.
The Legislature faces that rule too, but ignores it. It also gets away with it. The income tax law is a 109-page package. It also cuts sales tax on diapers and hygiene products, expands a small business exemption and grows the Working Families Tax Credit. Nobody in Olympia is losing sleep over logrolling when Democrats do it.
The newsrooms carrying the water
Democrats couldn’t pull this off without a press corps that treats their talking points as reporting.
In the Seattle Times poll story, left-wing reporter Jim Brunner described it as unfortunate for I-645 backers that the budget sentence will appear on the ballot. He never told readers the income tax currently funds zero schools. Brunner will co-moderate the October 8 I-645 debate KING 5 and the Seattle Times are hosting.
The Spokesman-Review republished a Seattle Times piece stating as fact, with no attribution, that the tax’s billions will largely fund K-12 schools, universities and healthcare. KING 5 told its audience the money is supposed to fund childcare, K-12 education and free school meals, again with no attribution. That’s the No on 645 pitch, delivered in a news voice.
These reporters should be embarrassed. They aren’t, because somewhere along the way they decided journalism means taking the side of the people in power, as long as those people are Democrats.
Who’s the king now?
Count the obstacles to voters getting a say in issues that impact them. Democrats block the referendum. The attorney general’s office helps them do it, then writes a ballot sentence against the repeal. A justice plucked from that office votes to keep it. If you win anyway, the Legislature rewrites your law or the Supreme Court tosses it.
Nobody is stuffing ballot boxes in Washington. They don’t have to. The only path left for conservatives and independents is winning by margins so lopsided no one can explain them away. Then they have to pray the Legislature doesn’t overturn them again.
And these are the people who call Donald Trump a fascist and a would-be king who ignores the will of the people. Jayapal worked the crowd at Seattle’s No Kings rally. She should try a mirror.
That’s exactly why staying home is the worst thing you can do: 511,408 of your neighbors signed anyway, and without the state’s sentence, this race is a coin flip. Voters crushed an income tax 64% to 36% in 2010, and the people who wrote this one know it, which is why they rigged everything around your ballot except your ability to fill it out. The system is stacked against us, so we don’t get to win by a little; we have to win by so much they can’t spin it, sue it, or legislate it away. Read past the state’s ad on your ballot, vote yes on 645, and make them explain why the will of the people still isn’t good enough.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
10 Comments
If the tax was repealed at the ballot box, Washington courts would overturn the election result and reinstate the tax.
Too bad this commentary isn’t widely read or distributed, it hit’s the nail on the head. The Golden Rule, “ye that has the gold, rules”. The Democrats have ALL the levers of power in this State and they are not afraid to jam that power right down our throats. Who will be left to pay the taxes in five years. I’m going.
The fix is already in. How else do you explain 40 plus years of Demo reign at the top. They have already filled out the bogus ballots for immigrants and the homeless. Votes for sale...a little immigration daycare fraud permission, and a vote for fetti gets it done. However despite their fraud and evil.bloodthirsty agenda, I'm still voting because I not want my lack of voter participation to be a partner to their fraudulent celebration.