ADVERTISEMENT

JASON RANTZ OPINION

Rantz: Activists lazily claim Everett crackdown on illicit massage parlors discriminates against Asians

Everett approved new penalties for illicit massage businesses suspected of prostitution. Activists claim the crackdown discriminates against Asian workers.

Everett City Council members seated during a public meeting at city hall...

Everett Mayor Cassie Franklin is asking the City Council for $5 million to launch the South Everett Futures Fund. (City of Everett)

(City of Everett)

The Everett City Council unanimously approved new criminal penalties for illicit massage businesses, and activists responded by claiming the crackdown discriminates against Asians. As if enforcing laws against selling sex out of a storefront is a civil rights violation.

The ordinance codifies civil penalties for violations of state massage regulations, creates misdemeanor penalties for unlicensed massage work and for sexual misconduct, trafficking, or prostitution inside massage businesses, and makes it a gross misdemeanor to direct others into prostitution, according to The Daily Herald. It also bans massage businesses from operating between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m. and allows unannounced city inspections during business hours. City attorney Lacey Offutt told the council in May that the number of illicit massage businesses in Everett and the region is growing at a steady pace.

None of that swayed the activists who showed up to fight the law with spurious claims of racism.

The ludicrous discrimination claim

The Massage Parlor Organizing Project, a Seattle-based advocacy group, argued the ordinance unfairly targets Asian immigrant massage workers because the state licensing process is expensive, time-consuming, and offers language accommodations only in English and Spanish. Under that logic, any licensing law becomes discriminatory the moment the people violating it are immigrants.

“Unlicensed Asian massage workers exist not because they do not know how to do their work, but because of the systemic barriers they face as low-income immigrants with limited English proficiency. Criminalization means marginalization, and under this era, it can also lead to deportation for workers,” Erica Wang told the council during public comment, seeming to admit that illegal immigrants are currently operating in the city.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is the same group that accused Bothell police of anti-Asian harassment after officers shut down five downtown massage businesses in April. Bothell police said their investigation produced solid evidence that the parlors were operating as sex businesses, not legitimate massage practices.

What the law actually targets

Offutt told the council the ordinance is aimed at the people running the operations, not the workers inside them.

“Our emphasis on enforcement will be on the folks who are more in charge or are putting people in compromising positions for their own economic gain,” Offutt said. “The bigger fish are the ones we really see as driving these businesses in the city and in the region, and to the extent we can enforce at that higher level, I think there’s definitely a desire to do that.”

Mayor Cassie Franklin defended the ordinance in a statement Thursday.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We are updating our code to establish clear enforcement mechanisms for unlicensed operations in an effort to combat illegal behavior. Our goal is to support public health and eliminate businesses that exploit workers,” Franklin wrote.

Even while passing the law, city leaders spent much of the meeting reassuring its opponents. Deputy mayor Mike Fong promised multilingual outreach through social workers before enforcement begins and pledged to push the Legislature to ease licensing barriers. The council approved the ordinance unanimously.

A regional proliferation of questionable massage parlors

Everett is not acting in a vacuum.

Bothell police raided five massage parlors in April on suspicion of prostitution and human trafficking, some of them operating within two blocks of the police station. Similar enforcement actions have spread across the Puget Sound region, from Bothell to Kirkland to Federal Way, as Seattle prepares to host FIFA World Cup matches this month.

ADVERTISEMENT

The activist argument never changes from city to city; every inspection, raid, and licensing requirement gets labeled racist. What goes unmentioned is who benefits when cities back off. If the trafficking allegations piling up across the region are accurate, the victims inside these businesses are overwhelmingly Asian immigrant women themselves. Walking away from enforcement does not shield them from discrimination. It leaves them with the people allegedly profiting off their exploitation.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

4 Comments

G
Gunnar gunnar 5 months ago

But where we to get our happy ending?

J
Jake Morningwood 5 months ago

When you don't have a good argument to support your position just cry racism. It's all the left has because none of their arguments can pass a common sense test.

C
Clockwork Wyrm 5 months ago

The fact that they made human trafficking a gross misdemeanor is an affront to justice. Human trafficking is one of the most heinous crimes our society endures and it should be treated with the seriousness it deserves.

Unannounced inspections is outrageous government overreach. The private property owner has rights and they should be afforded at minimum, a 24 hour notice prior to an inspection occurring. Crime occurs frequently on private property but that doesn't give the government the authority to generally waive all private property rights.