Trucking executive who sold Washington carrier to Iowa says state has become ‘unknowable’ for capital
Former Gordon Trucking owner Steve Gordon warns Washington's 9.9% income tax has turned the state into an 'unknowable' risk that capital refuses to absorb.
Steve Gordon, former owner of Pacific Northwest carrier Gordon Trucking, says Washington's tax instability drove his decision to sell to an Iowa-based competitor. (Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images)
(Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images)
Steve Gordon, the former owner of Gordon Trucking who built the Pacific Northwest carrier from his grandfather’s WWII-era startup into a 2,000-truck national operation before selling to Iowa-based Heartland Express in 2013, is warning that Washington state’s tax climate has crossed the line from expensive to unworkable.
In a post published Sunday on X, Gordon argues that the 9.9% income tax Democrats just enacted is only the latest symptom of a much deeper problem, and that the business community is finished pretending otherwise.
Gordon’s piece reads as an open letter from inside the freight industry that hauls roughly 70% of everything on Washington store shelves. He spent 25 years making capital decisions at a company that put $100 million a year into diesel alone, ran terminals from Usk, Washington to Temple, Texas, and served as a core carrier for Wal-Mart, Costco, Amazon, Anheuser-Busch, Georgia Pacific, Home Depot, Lowes, Procter & Gamble, General Mills and Kellogg’s. He says he has a better read on the business community than the politicians writing the rules.
A trucking executive makes the case against Olympia
Gordon opened with a shot at the political class that passed SB 6346.
“It seems there’s a little public debate about taxation going on in Washington state. Democrats in charge of every lever of government, believe that the ‘wealthy’ need to pay more, or more charitably, ‘their fair share.’ And by implementing a constitutionally questionable income tax, they’re asserting that amount starts at 9.9% on adjusted gross worldwide income, with a one million dollar deductible. Those targeted in this latest revenue grab (and a whole bunch who aren’t currently on that list) are answering, ‘Not So Fast,'” Gordon wrote.
He then aimed at Gov. Bob Ferguson, Sen. Jamie Pedersen, House Speaker Laurie Jinkins, Rep. Noel Frame and Rep. April Berg, naming each of the Democrats as part of a leadership class he says is out of touch with the people who actually run Washington’s tangible-goods economy.
Gordon also dismissed the talking point that the latest tax hike is somehow about catching up to inflation and population growth, citing a recent Office of Financial Management letter that he says shows the state still won’t have enough revenue even with the income tax in place. The conclusion he draws is that the 9.9% rate is a floor, not a ceiling.
Why the rules keep changing on capital
The strongest part of Gordon’s argument is not about the rate itself. It is about the constant rewriting of the math.
“When we’d put several million into a new terminal, the payback ran a decade or more. You underwrite it against assumptions about volume, wages, fuel; and the cost of operating in that jurisdiction. In Washington, those assumptions don’t hold. The B&O changes, a compliance fee appears, a ‘temporary’ assessment gets extended, the CCA hits fuel; and now 9.9% on top. None of it was in the model when the shovel went in the ground. Every session, the legislature reaches back and rewrites a calculation the business already committed to,” Gordon stated.
That, he argues, is what is actually driving the exodus tracked by the Association of Washington Business survey, where 91% of responding employers say they will not invest further in the state.
“That’s not a tax level problem; it’s a tax uncertainty problem, and it’s worse. A high but stable burden you can price and bid into your rates. What you can’t price is a government that treats long-lived capital as a renewable revenue source, revisited every January. The algebra isn’t just expensive; it’s unknowable. And unknowable is the one thing capital won’t sit still for. So it leaves; the expansion that goes to Idaho, the facility that never gets built,” he wrote.
The C-corp silence and the pass-through pain
Gordon also called out the quiet players in the room. The income tax, he noted, was carefully written to hit pass-through entities like S-corps and LLCs while leaving the state’s largest public companies untouched. That, he argued, explains why Amazon, Microsoft and the Washington Roundtable have gone silent while small and mid-sized employers absorb the blow.
“The income tax is specifically designed to capture pass-through business income, but leaves out C-corps like the state’s largest public companies. There’s a reason they and the WA Roundtable are silent; it’s in their own self-interest to sit this fight out. But those impacted have seen enough. We are ranked 45th by the Tax Foundation on competitiveness already. While proponents of the income tax center their case on ‘regressivity,’ the business community makes decisions based on the competitiveness assessment and their own impression of ‘fair share.’ And they’re voting, with their feet,” Gordon argued.
He closed with a warning aimed directly at the lawmakers who just spent the session selling SB 6346 as a painless way to make somebody else pay.
“Policy leaders and their friends with little connectivity to the business community can continue to ignore the evidence, but do so at the peril of Washington’s economic vitality. The residents who stay will be left with the tab. And their collective bank account is just about overdrawn…,” Gordon concluded.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
3 Comments
Thank you Steve for for an accurate and educated response.
Forget the magic 8-ball, this is why and where the rubber meets the road.
Steve Gordon should run for Governor. At least he understands how business works.