Rantz: Seattle Police Chief Shon Barnes’ defenders can only obsess over his race
The coalition rallying to save Seattle Chief Shon Barnes never mentions his absences, his ethics problems, or the reporter he nearly fought. Only his race.
Seattle Police Chief Shon Barnes addresses the media during a news conference July 28. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Channel)
(Photo courtesy of the Seattle Channel)
A coalition of Seattle civil rights groups, nonprofits, and clergy demanded Mayor Katie Wilson reverse her decision to remove Police Chief Shon Barnes. In an open letter explaining their anger, no where does the coalition address a single one of the reasons Barnes lost the job.
The open letter published by The Seattle Medium is signed by the Seattle NAACP, the Urban League of Metropolitan Seattle, Byrd Barr Place, 100 Black Parents, Community Passageways, Parents for Student Success, and the MLK Coalition. It calls the firing a scapegoating. It calls for stability. It asks Wilson to weigh outcomes rather than headlines. And then it tells you what the actual argument is.
“Black leadership matters,” the letter reads. “Chief Barnes should be evaluated by facts, integrity, and outcomes not politics or headlines.”
Fine. Let’s do exactly that.
The facts they asked Seattle to consider
Barnes was not in the city when three people were murdered and four more were wounded, including a 2-year-old, at a family food festival on public property. He was in Dallas at a conference. His department went roughly five hours without telling the public anything, and Assistant Chief Tyrone Davis had to run the only briefing the city managed that night.
“I was not in town yesterday. I wish that I had a crystal ball and we could schedule gun violence, but we can’t,” Barnes told reporters the next morning. Public speaking is not his strong suit, which is a key job requirement. He wishes he could schedule gun violence? I wish we could prevent it.
Nobody expects a crystal ball. People expect a chief who is reachable and a command staff trained to speak when he is not. This was also not the first time. Seattle Red and PubliCola reported that Barnes was out of town during a major SPD incident at Cal Anderson Park in May 2025, when officers pepper-sprayed and arrested dozens of counter-protesters, and Barnes told that outlet at the time that expecting one person to be available around the clock was unrealistic.
Scandal-plagued Barnes
Then there is everything else the letter skips.
Barnes collected two $1,000 referral bonuses for hiring command staff he personally appointed. He billed taxpayers $33,000 to sponsor a basketball tournament tied to his alma mater in Baltimore while refusing to say how often he flies to Chicago, where his family lives. He was eating lunch across the street during a $2 million jewelry heist and did not know it was happening.
And this week he nearly came to blows with a reporter who asked him a fair question about his travel, on camera, one day after the massacre. Barnes had to be escorted out of the room.
None of that appears in the letter. Not one line.
Representation is not a performance review
The coalition insists one incident should not erase a record of work and progress. Agreed. It was never one incident, and the people who wrote that claim know it, because these are organizations with staff who read the news.
What they have done instead is reduce the leadership of a police department in the middle of a violent crime crisis to a question of who holds the title. To them, Barnes is qualified because Barnes is black. That is the load-bearing claim, and once you make it, chronic absenteeism becomes a distraction, ethics questions become noise, and a chief squaring up to fight a journalist becomes a headline problem rather than a temperament problem.
The irony gets thicker. The National Organization of Black Law Enforcement Executives signed on to the coalition, according to KIRO 7. NOBLE is the group whose Dallas conference had Barnes out of the state when the shooting started.
Who actually pays for this
The gunfire at Bite of Seattle was gang-related, according to police, and the neighborhoods hit hardest by that violence are the same neighborhoods the NAACP and the Urban League supposedly exist to serve. Those residents do not need a chief who represents them at conferences. They need one who is in town, who answers the phone, and who builds a command structure that functions when he is not standing at the podium.
Wilson deserves criticism for how her own office handled the aftermath, and she will get plenty of it from me. But she made the correct personnel decision, and the coalition demanding she undo it has offered little to argue with except identity.
If black leadership matters then it should be held to the same standard as everyone else. Lowering the bar to protect one man is not advocacy. It is condescension dressed up as solidarity, and Seattle’s actual crime victims are the ones who pay the price.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
6 Comments
“Race” is their sole trading stock. Meritocracy be damned! Let’s hope the “mayor” looks squarely in the mirror and asks for their own resignation too. I’d be down with a 2’fer!
Well, let's see. Black Chief Barnes brought in Black Deputy Chief Sayles from Wisconsin. Black Chief of Staff Ricketts. Black Female assistant Chief Powell. The two white females on his command staff are SPD Veterans.
Why was DC Sayles made acting chief? 20 years rising through the ranks in a department that had 74 officers. Why not DC Underwood? White Female, rose through the SPD ranks in her 29 years in SPD (1100+ Officers).
Is Sayles an identity hire? Of course.
Barnes was another DEI hire, way over his skis.