ADVERTISEMENT

HOUSING

Good news, bad news: Washington Democrats’ income tax fuels a Seattle buyer’s market

Washington Democrats' income tax and capital gains hikes triggered a Seattle housing exodus. Buyers are now cashing in on falling prices and rising inventory.

Redfin for-sale sign in front of a Seattle-area home as Washington housing inventory surges and buy...

A for-sale sign outside a Seattle-area home as Washington's income tax exodus floods the market with listings in 2026. (Photo: Stephen Brashear, Getty Images for Redfin)

(Photo: Stephen Brashear, Getty Images for Redfin)

Washington Democrats spent five straight legislative sessions taxing high earners, and Seattle’s real estate market is now dealing with the wreckage, with sellers who can’t find buyers and a Puget Sound housing glut nobody in Olympia predicted.

The capital gains tax, the graduated real estate excise tax, and now Senate Bill 6346’s 9.9 percent income tax have pushed the state’s wealthiest homeowners toward the exits, and their departures flooded the market with listings faster than anyone can absorb them.

For any buyer who has been priced out of Seattle for a decade, that math is finally breaking in your favor. But will prices continue to drop?

Democrats taxed the sellers right out of the state

Washington Democrats passed a tax on capital gains above $250,000 and presented it as an “excise tax” to dodge the state constitution’s ban on an income tax. That same trick got another workout this year.

Senate Majority Leader Jamie Pedersen (D-Seattle) wrote in an internal email, later obtained and published, “I would like to force the Washington Supreme Court to reconsider its caselaw that considers income to be property.” Those emails showed SB 6346 was built from the start as a legal test case, not an honest tax bill. It’s precisely why Democrats balked at writing the legislation specific to millionaires.

Gov. Bob Ferguson signed SB 6346 into law in March, creating the state’s first income tax and hitting household earnings above $1 million at 9.9 percent starting in 2028. The reaction was immediate. Fifty-three homes priced above $2 million hit the market in a single day, and luxury listings statewide jumped roughly 65 percent overnight.

ADVERTISEMENT

Starbucks founder Howard Schultz announced he and his wife were leaving Seattle for Florida the night the House passed the bill. Jeff Bezos had already left over the capital gains tax, reportedly walking away from an estimated $610 million in state taxes with that single move.

Sellers are stuck and buyers are scarce

King County lost more than 68,000 taxpayers in 2023 alone, a net loss of $2.2 billion in adjusted gross income, according to a Puget Sound Business Journal analysis. Seattle now has the second largest home price drop of any city in the country, per Redfin’s own reporting. Seattle’s housing inventory had climbed to roughly 88 percent above a normal April, with 8,630 homes for sale compared to about 4,600 in a typical year.

Finance executive Adam Wright laid out the problem in a LinkedIn post that went viral in Washington business circles this spring.

“This ‘millionaire tax’ (SB 6346) is a huge mistake. It relies on a very small group (about 20-30K households who already pay roughly a third of all state taxes) staying put. That’s the assumption everything hinges on,” Wright wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

His breakdown of the bill’s math went viral for a reason; the state is betting billions in revenue on people not doing exactly what they are already doing.

A window buyers have not seen in years

For everyday buyers who gave up on Seattle years ago, the flood of Democrat-driven listings is turning into leverage. Matt Goyer, owner of the Seattle brokerage Urban Living, wrote in his weekly market newsletter this week that sellers are running out of patience.

“Sellers whose homes have been sitting are starting to wonder where everyone went,” Goyer wrote. He also warned anyone still waiting to list before the market goes quiet for the rest of summer. “Want to sell before Labor Day? Cut your price now. You have about a week or two before Seattle completely empties out for vacation.”

This might be somewhat good news for buyers who can find a better deal. But this is potentially catastrophic news for sellers, especially if they’re forced to drop prices even lower in the coming weeks and months.

ADVERTISEMENT

Housing calamity by design

None of what we’re experiencing in the housing market is a coincidence. It is the direct result of a tax policy that gave thousands of sellers a reason to leave at once, and it means buyers with steady jobs and financing lined up have negotiating power they have not had in years. Voters get their own say come November, when Let’s Go Washington’s Initiative 645 repeal effort reaches the ballot.

Democrats built this housing glut one tax bill at a time, and now the same voters they taxed into leaving are handing a discount to whoever is left to buy. If you can still afford a mortgage in Washington this summer, enjoy it while it lasts.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

3 Comments

J
Joseph Mueller 4 months ago

This is a 9.9% income tax on ALL Washingtonians:

Sec. 201. TAX IMPOSED—RATES. (1) Beginning January 1, 2028, a tax is imposed on the receipt of Washington taxable income. Only individuals are subject to payment of the tax, which equals 9.90 percent multiplied by an individual's Washington taxable income.

...with a $1,000,000 standard deduction: (which could easily change)

Sec. 314. ONE MILLION DOLLAR STANDARD DEDUCTION. In computing a taxpayer's Washington taxable income, a taxpayer may deduct from the taxpayer's Washington base income a standard deduction of $1,000,000 per individual, or in the case of spouses or state registered domestic partners, their combined standard deduction is $1,000,000, regardless of whether they file joint or separate returns.

Note that 2 individuals each get the $1,000,000 deduction, but if they're married, they get a 100% marriage penalty! Will this cause people to get divorced who make more than $1,000,000 combined? For a couple who makes $2M combined taxable income, it would save them $99,000/yr, LOL. I would just leave and rent my house out - take the 27.5 years of depreciation as a write-off. Or just establish domicile in Florida and live in the Seattle house in the summer.

E
Evan Lattimore 4 months ago

Prices dropping will also cascade into even more houses on the market, with sellers who were previously on the fence not wanting to miss out on the best price as they watch the value of their home drop. So called "leadership" in Seattle and Washington state is a rudderless mess.

J
Jason Pantz 4 months ago

They said they wanted to work on affordable housing. Looks like they found a way. Too bad there’ll be no jobs left but hey, an apartment will be a little less now that no one will want to live here.