ADVERTISEMENT

HOUSING

Seattle, Tacoma rank among worst U.S. cities for first-time home buyers; two surprising bright spots

A new WalletHub study ranks Seattle and Tacoma among the worst U.S. cities for first-time home buyers.

a for sale sign outside a seattle home...

A new WalletHub study rates Tacoma among the five worst cities in the country for first-time home buyers, with Seattle's near-$865,000 median keeping the rest of Puget Sound out of reach. (Photo: Stephen Brashear via Getty Images for Redfin)

(Photo: Stephen Brashear via Getty Images for Redfin)

Seattle and Tacoma are one of the worst cities in America for first-time home buyers, according to a new WalletHub study. Seattle was ranked 204th and Tacoma 190th out of 300.

The 2026 report graded 300 U.S. cities on 22 measures of affordability, market health, and quality of life, then sorted them from best to worst. The poor placement for Seattle is not necessarily a shock. Thanks to far-left policies, the city has become remarkably unaffordable, with quality of life suffering due to crime and homelessness. But Tacoma’s ranking is shocking. For a city sold for years as the affordable escape from Seattle, 190th is a stunning place to end up.

The ranking says as much about the wider Puget Sound market as it does about Seattle and Tacoma. Washington has built one of the most punishing entry-level housing markets in the country, the same market where Seattle recently posted the worst home-price performance of any major U.S. city, and the buyers trying to break in are the ones who feel it first.

Tacoma was supposed to be the affordable option

Buyers priced out of Seattle spent years leaning on Tacoma as the reasonable alternative, close to the job centers and cheap enough to make ownership possible. That pitch has worn thin.

Tacoma’s median sale price sat around $485,000 in March according to Redfin, down about 1% from a year earlier, while Pierce County’s single-family median climbed to roughly $605,000 in June under the Northwest Multiple Listing Service.

Prices softened at the edges, yet local wages never caught up, and that gap is what WalletHub measures. The study weights housing affordability, calculated as median home price divided by median household income, more heavily than nearly any other factor. Tacoma fails that test, and the buyers who once treated it as a cheaper backup are hitting the same wall that pushed them out of Seattle in the first place.

ADVERTISEMENT

The only Washington bright spots were Spokane at 33 and Spokane Valley at 29. Everett placed at 125th.

Seattle keeps first-time buyers locked out

The median home price in Seattle still hovers near $865,000, and a Seattle-area buyer now needs to earn close to $219,000 a year to afford a typical home, a level MyNorthwest reported is out of reach for most working families. Only about 14% of local listings qualify as affordable, against 33% nationally, and King County’s median held near $889,000 in June, second only to San Juan County.

Washington has stacked cost on cost, from a capital gains tax that pushed high earners toward Texas and Florida to permit fees baked into every new unit. First-time buyers made up just 21% of the national market last year, down from a historical average of 40%, according to the National Association of Realtors, and the 30-year fixed mortgage rate averaged 6.49% in late June, adding hundreds of dollars to payments that were already stretched.

ADVERTISEMENT

The best markets share what Washington rejects

Of the cities that topped the list, three are from Florida, and five from Arizona. Boise, Idaho also cracks the top ten. All are run on a formula Washington keeps refusing to emulate.

The cities and states on the list build homes, they tax lightly, and they let supply meet demand. Nine of the ten worst-ranked cities were in California, the one state whose housing politics Washington seems most eager to match.

Tacoma near the bottom and Seattle’s price wall above it are the result of a decade of policy that treats housing as a revenue source. The people locked out are young families and first-job workers who were promised a foothold and handed a closed door.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments