Washington has the most to lose if SCOTUS ends mail ballot grace periods in Watson v. RNC
Conservative Supreme Court justices signaled Monday they're done with mail ballot grace periods. Washington's 21-day window — the longest in the nation — faces elimination in Watson v. RNC.
The U.S. Supreme Court will review three Washington laws that let runaway minors access gender care while limiting parental notice and reunification. (Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)
(Photo by Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)
Washington state has the longest mail ballot grace period in the nation. If the Supreme Court’s conservative majority has its way, that window could disappear in a matter of months.
The high court heard oral arguments Monday in Watson v. Republican National Committee, a case that could fundamentally rewrite how mail votes are counted across 14 states, plus the District of Columbia. Washington sits at the extreme end of the exposure list. While the Mississippi law being challenged allows ballots to arrive up to five days after Election Day, Washington’s grace period runs a full 21 days, easily the longest in the country. The state certifies general elections at that same 21-day mark.
If SCOTUS rules that federal law requires ballots to be received by Election Day, Washington state faces a total overhaul of how its all-mail election system works, on a short clock, before November’s midterms.
The Watson v. RNC case and what’s at stake for mail ballot laws
The case before the high court, known as Watson v. RNC, involves Mississippi’s deadline for late-arriving mail ballots and whether its law, as well as similar measures from 13 other states, conflicts with federal statutes that set Election Day as the Tuesday after the first Monday in November.
In striking down Mississippi’s grace period, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that federal law requires all ballots to be received by Election Day. Mississippi appealed, and the Supreme Court agreed in November to weigh in.
The dispute turns on what “election” actually means under federal law. Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch, a Republican, argued that neither ballot receipt nor ballot counting is part of the “election.” “Counting votes is not part of the election,” Fitch told the court. The RNC argues the opposite — that an election isn’t over until officials have received the ballots.
Conservative justices signal the end of mail ballot grace periods
Over more than two hours, justices raised a number of reasons why they saw those policies as problematic, seemingly embracing Republicans’ arguments that the state laws run afoul of statutes passed by Congress establishing Election Day in November for federal offices.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh raised the question of public confidence in close races directly. “If the apparent winner the morning after the election ends up losing due to late-arriving ballots, charges of a rigged election could explode,” Kavanaugh said. Justice Samuel Alito was blunt about the status quo. “We don’t have Election Day anymore,” Alito said. “We have election month, or we have election months.”
Justices appeared largely sympathetic to the arguments made by Trump’s Solicitor General D. John Sauer, who noted that the Mississippi law and other late-arriving mail-in ballot laws could erode voter confidence in election results. In an amicus brief, Sauer wrote that “ensuring all ballot boxes close on the same day eliminates incentives and opportunities for fraudulent abuse.”
Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett could be the deciding votes on the matter, and used their time to ask tough questions to lawyers for both sides. The court’s liberal justices indicated they would uphold state grace periods, largely on the grounds that states should control their own election rules.
What a Watson v. RNC ruling would mean for Washington state’s election system
Washington is not a state with a modest grace period that could be trimmed quietly. It is an all-mail voting state where every registered voter receives a ballot, every vote travels through the postal system or delivered to a drop box or election office, and elections are certified 21 days after general elections by Secretary of State Steve Hobbs, with ballots being processed continuously throughout that window.
In Washington, there is no fixed deadline written into state law for when ballots must arrive after Election Day. Instead, county election officials continue accepting and processing ballots as they arrive, so long as they were mailed on time. A ruling requiring ballots to land at election offices by Election Day would make that system illegal for federal races.
Republicans looking to interest the justices in taking up the issue could have sued in New York, Illinois or Washington, among other states with relaxed deadlines for receiving mailed ballots. But they chose heavily Republican Mississippi to put the case in front of the 5th Circuit, where a panel of three Trump appointees struck down the state law. The legal strategy was shrewd. The consequences will not be limited to Mississippi.
A final ruling will almost certainly come by late June, early enough to govern the counting of ballots in the 2026 midterm congressional elections. That gives Washington a narrow window to inform voters, retrain county officials, and rewrite guidance across 39 county election departments, all while a statewide primary is already underway.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
0 Comments