Washington Supreme Court strikes down voter-approved natural gas initiative
The Washington Supreme Court struck down I-2066 in a 6-3 ruling, voiding natural gas protections nearly 2 million voters approved. Let's Go Washington responds.
The Washington State Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that Initiative 2066, the voter-approved natural gas protection measure, is unconstitutional in its entirety. (Photo courtesy of Washington Supreme Court)
(Photo courtesy of Washington Supreme Court)
The Washington State Supreme Court struck down Initiative 2066 on Thursday, erasing the natural gas protections that nearly two million voters approved in November 2024. The justices ruled 6-3 that the measure violated the state constitution’s single-subject rule, which limits an initiative to a single subject.
I-2066 was filed by the Building Industry Association of Washington to stop state and local government from banning, restricting, or discouraging natural gas service. It repealed sections of House Bill 1589, the 2024 law pushing Puget Sound Energy away from gas, and it undid energy code provisions that make gas heat costlier to install in new construction. Let’s Go Washington and the Washington Hospitality Association backed the campaign. Climate Solutions, Washington Conservation Action, Front and Centered, King County, and the city of Seattle sued to void it, continuing a legal campaign against the 2024 initiative slate that Attorney General Bob Ferguson quietly handled without telling initiative sponsors or voters.
What the court decided
Chief Justice Debra Stephens wrote for the majority that the initiative packed together provisions with distinct purposes and regulatory effects, amounting to four separate subjects under Article II, Section 19. The majority found no way to salvage any piece of it.
“It is not possible by judicial construction to sever and save any of the separate provisions and therefore I-2066 is unconstitutional in its entirety,” Stephens wrote.
King County Superior Court Judge Sandra Widlan had already invalidated the measure in March 2025 on multiple constitutional grounds, a ruling initiative supporters appealed directly to the high court. Thursday’s decision affirmed her, but only on the single-subject question. Attorney General Nick Brown defended the initiative on appeal despite saying he personally opposed it, arguing that his job is to enforce laws Washington voters pass.
Justice Salvador Mungia dissented, joined by Justices Charles Johnson and Sheryl Gordon McCloud. He would have excised the provisions he considered defective and preserved the remainder of the measure.
“Courts are required to construe initiatives in favor of constitutionality when possible,” Mungia wrote. “This court can uphold much of I-2066 as constitutional and should do so.”
Let’s Go Washington calls it a coordinated effort
Let’s Go Washington, the political action committee behind a string of initiatives Democrats and the courts have worked to dismantle, released a statement obtained by Seattle Red. Founder Brian Heywood accused every branch of state government of moving against the initiative process itself.
“Today’s decision by the Supreme Court is shameful, not only because it punishes families making heating their homes more expensive, but because it appears to be a coordinated effort by all three branches of the government to annihilate the initiative process itself,” Heywood said. “More than two million Washingtonians voted for I-2066. They made their decision and exercised a constitutional right reserved for the people. Today, that decision was erased by a biased and one-sided court.”
The group argues citizens now face a stricter drafting standard than the Legislature does, given how routinely Olympia passes omnibus bills that amend dozens of statutes across unrelated policy areas.
“We are seeing a troubling double standard unfurling in our state government: one set of rules for government officials and legislators when they make policy and an infinite number of barriers for the people when they attempt to voice their concerns,” Heywood said.
What this means for the next ballot measure
The statement also cites bills introduced this session to make initiatives harder to qualify, including a requirement that sponsors gather 1,000 signatures before receiving a ballot title and new limits on how signature gatherers may be compensated. Washington Democrats also wrote this year’s 9.9 percent income tax without any contingency on voter approval, structuring it to restrict the people’s referendum power.
That leaves Washington voters carrying rising utility bills and a grid state officials have warned is heading toward shortfalls, with the one tool they had to push back now weaker than it was Wednesday.
“Justice Mungia’s dissent concluded that I-2066’s provisions shared a rational connection to the initiative’s stated purpose and warned that Washington courts are supposed to construe initiatives in a manner that protects, rather than unnecessarily defeats, the people’s legislative power,” Heywood said. “Washingtonians should ask whether their constitutional check on government is being steadily hollowed out.”
Let’s Go Washington is urging a yes vote on all three of its initiatives this November.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
17 Comments
You know what the next step is?
Get four initiatives set to go that say;
#1 - The state shall not DISCOURAGE the use of Natural Gas
#2 - The state shall not RESTRICT the use of Natural Gas
#3 - The state shall not BAN the use of Natural Gas
#4 - The state shall REPEAL all code provisions that make gas heat costlier to install in new construction
Or we could make it easier by voting OUT the Marxist/Socialist legislators and judges.
I see a pattern. If only we had some examples (sarc) Two million citizens be damed. Your voice doesn't seem to matter here!
The tyranny of government continues. It is reasonable to conclude the WA judiciary is full of activists and those that collude with the party in power.