Five Tukwila workers quit their union and it kept billing them anyway, so they went after a federal precedent: claim
Five Tukwila workers say SMART Local 55 kept taking union dues after their contract expired. They want the NLRB to scrap the 1979 precedent that allows it.
Five Holaday-Parks workers in Tukwila are challenging an NLRB precedent that let SMART Local 55 keep deducting union dues after their contract expired. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
(Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Five Tukwila workers say a sheet metal union kept pulling dues from their paychecks after the contract expired and they quit, and now they want a 47-year-old federal precedent thrown out.
Brittani Butler and four coworkers at Holaday-Parks, Inc. filed unfair labor practice charges with the National Labor Relations Board against the International Association of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers (SMART) Local 55, according to the National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation, which announced the charges Tuesday and is representing the workers pro bono. The union took the money and ignored the workers, and federal precedent says that is allowed.
The precedent is Frito-Lay, Inc., a 1979 NLRB decision that lets a union confine a worker’s right to cancel a dues-checkoff authorization to a short window the union itself sets, even when no collective bargaining agreement is in force. The Foundation says that contradicts the Labor Management Relations Act, which lets workers revoke a dues authorization once a contract ends. Washington is not a Right to Work state, so unions here keep exclusive bargaining power over every worker in a unit, including those who never signed up.
How the Tukwila dues fight started
After Holaday-Parks’ contract with Local 55 expired, Butler and four coworkers resigned their union membership and revoked their checkoff authorizations. Local 55 continued collecting dues from their paychecks and did not respond to a single request, the Foundation said. Because they filed outside the union’s revocation window, Frito-Lay gives Local 55 cover to keep deducting.
Cypress Meadowlark, an employee at Wayne Sanderson Farms in Hammond, Louisiana, hit the same wall with United Food and Commercial Workers Local 455. She resigned and revoked her authorization before the union signed a new agreement with her employer, and UFCW officials kept taking dues anyway, according to the Foundation.
A Trump-era push the Board never finished
In 2019, then-NLRB General Counsel Peter Robb directed the agency’s regional offices to bring cases aimed at overturning Frito-Lay. The precedent survived, and Foundation President Mark Mix wants the new NLRB majority to finish what Robb started.
“It’s outrageous that for nearly 50 years the NLRB’s outrageous Frito-Lay decision has continued to grant union bosses the privilege to keep siphoning dues out of the pockets of dissenting workers, even when the underlying ‘justification’ for the dues payments no longer exists,” Mix said in a statement. “The new NLRB majority should finish the job started during the last Trump administration and overturn Frito-Lay to ensure that no worker can be trapped into funding a union against their will when there is not even a valid contract in effect between a union and employer.”
Washington unions have fought to keep collecting from unwilling workers before. University of Washington employees sued in 2020 after SEIU 925 made it difficult to stop paying dues once the Supreme Court’s Janus ruling made payment optional. If there is no contract, what exactly are the dues paying for?
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments