ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Supreme Court grants emergency hearing for Brian Heywood’s income tax challenge

Washington Supreme Court fast-tracks Brian Heywood's challenge against the state's use of "emergency clauses" to block an income tax referendum.

High court hears challenge to income tax 'emergency.' (Getty Images)...

The separation of powers is a critical component of our constitutional order (Getty Images)

(Getty Images)

The fight over Washington’s new income tax is heading straight to the state’s highest court. Brian Heywood, the founder of Let’s Go Washington, has successfully moved his challenge to the Washington State Supreme Court after the Secretary of State blocked a public referendum on the tax. Usually, reaching the Supreme Court is a year-long process, but the court has granted an emergency hearing for April 30.

“They’ve taken it seriously. They’re looking at it—it doesn’t mean they’re going to rule in our favor… but they took it seriously, which we appreciate,” Heywood told The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. He hasn’t had to collect a single signature yet because the case currently centers on whether the state can use a “necessity clause” to block the public from voting on new laws.

Challenging the ‘emergency’ loophole

The core of the lawsuit is the legislature’s frequent use of “emergency” or “necessity” clauses to prevent referendums. Heywood’s team discovered that out of 268 laws passed this last year, 23 of them Included these clauses. Heywood argues that a well-functioning legislature should only use such measures for true emergencies, perhaps 0.5% of the time.

“What we’re arguing is an original meaning of the Constitution, as opposed to the Secretary of State’s interpretation and the legislature’s interpretation,” Heywood explained. “I don’t believe there is a necessity clause in the Constitution. There’s this emergency clause that they’ve put an ‘or’ in that makes them claim there’s a necessity clause.”

Heywood points out the irony of calling the income tax an “emergency” when the state won’t even start collecting the funds for over two years.

ADVERTISEMENT

If the Supreme Court rules in Heywood’s favor, Let’s Go Washington will immediately begin a signature blitz. Because a referendum only requires 200,000 signatures—and lacks the confusing financial impact statements required for other initiatives—Heywood believes they can easily get it on the ballot this November.

The $450 million gamble

Beyond the legal hurdle, Heywood warned about the infrastructure the state is building to enforce the tax. He noted that the Department of Revenue was just allocated $450 million to set up collection systems.

“That means they’ve got to collect $5 billion worth of wealth taxes just to break even,” Heywood said. He also referenced data suggesting that if just 2,300 wealthy residents leave the state to avoid the tax, the entire financial plan collapses.

“I find often I run into people that say, ‘Well, we’re going to lose anyway, so don’t try.’ And it means that we’ve basically given the other side just a freebie,” Heywood said. “It’s really not in my nature to just let that slide by when something seems very obvious.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jasneet Gill Content Editor

Jasneet Gill is a content editor and writer for Seattle Red. She is a Washington native, born and raised in the state, and a graduate of the University of Washington with a bachelor's degree in Communications. Her passion for soccer led her to play… Read more

Comments

3 Comments

C
Candis Gauvin 8 months ago

The new taxis illegal and the supreme court needs to overturn it.

D
Doug Spittler 8 months ago

This whole debacle may have been a boon for Washingtonians. Whilst Progressive Socialists/Leftists were wasting mountains of time attempting to force what is almost guaranteed to be an illegal tax down our throats, they lacked the time to be able to foist off a great deal of other, even more onerous nonsense on "we, the people".

S
Shawn m 8 months ago

"There’s this emergency clause that they’ve put an ‘or’ in that makes them claim there’s a necessity clause."

This sounds like classic Ferguson.

Remember the HOV lanes being built on I-405 between Bellevue and Bothell? Once completed, metrics had to be met after a two-year trial period for the program to survive: Reduction of traffic congestion by a certain amount, and average speeds targets had to be met. Both failed despite additional metrics succeeding, but the deal was predicated on all metrics succeeding and they did not.

Then AG Ferguson argued that "and" actually meant "or" which may be the only reason the HOV system survived to increasingly gouge travelers daily.