Taxpayers bled dry as WA pays unprecedented amount for outside legal help to keep up with caseloads
The state of Washington has spent over $40 million in the past fiscal year alone on outside legal help to keep up with the increasingly high number of cases.
WA Attorney General Nick Brown's office is paying millions in private legal help to manage caseloads. (Screengrab: TVW)
(Screengrab: TVW)
Over the past fiscal year, the state of Washington has spent $43.6 million on outside legal help, according to data from the WA Department of Enterprise Services.
That number has grown by five-fold since 2023 when the state only paid $8.7 million on such contracts. Public records show the state paid only $283,000 in 2020.
Some private lawyers can charge over $300 an hour, which is far more expensive than having assistant attorneys general employed by the state do the same work. The state is also paying hundreds of millions in legal settlements and taxpayers will be charged $4.4 billion in lawsuit costs over the next several years, according actuarial analysis.
The state can’t keep up with caseloads
State officials say they have no choice but to hire outside help in order to keep up with an increasingly high caseload, particularly against the Department of Children, Youth and Families.
“Every lawsuit has to be defended,” Scott Barbara, chief of the civil division for Attorney General Nick Brown’s office, told The Seattle Times. “Is it more expensive? Absolutely.”
Barbara says the state torts division, which deals with civil lawsuits, has roughly 600 actives cases assigned to private attorneys. In 2019, only four cases were handled by private attorneys.
“There is no expectation that their [the private attorneys’] performance is going to be different from the work of the assistant attorneys general,” added Barbara. “We look to them to be handling the cases responsibly, competently, consistently.”
Barbara says the civil division has about 200 full-time employees and 66 attorneys. Filling vacancies has been difficult because salaries even for an experienced assistant attorney general is capped at $157,000.
Daniel Hsieh, president of the Association of Washington Assistant Attorneys General, the union representing the state’s attorneys told The Seattle Times it would take 70 to 80 more attorneys to handle the caseloads.
The looming fiscal crisis
Democrats are being forced to reckon with the fact that the state’s current trajectory is untenable for a state facing a roughly $16 billion budget deficits.
“We cannot continue to go up at this increase of paying billions of dollars that the state cannot afford,” Attorney General Nick Brown said in a recent interview with TVW.
A tort study committee is expected to submit potential cost-cutting measures to Governor Bob Ferguson ahead of next year’s legislative session. Possible proposals include damage caps and resolving decades-old abuse lawsuits via a compensation fund rather than through the courts.
This will likely receive blowback from advocates and attorneys for abuse survivors who believe that fixing the systemic issues within the much-maligned DCYF would be the more effective route.
Hsieh argues that increasing pay for the Attorney’s General Office would also help remedy staffing issues. The Office of Financial Management says assistant attorneys general in Washington receive 20% less pay than in other states.
“We could be out in practice making more money,” Hsieh told The Seattle Times. “We are not asking for millions, but just something that keeps up with inflation.”
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.





Comments
4 Comments
to begin with sideshow ferguson and sewer brown need to go. this is the result of their ineptitude
They would need more lawyers.
Yet another example of the financial/economic ignorance of the masses, who believe there is such a thing as a "free" lunch - then complain about high taxes.
"Among the biggest lies of the welfare states on both sides of the Atlantic is the notion that the government can supply the people with things they want but cannot afford. Since the government gets its resources from the people, if the people as a whole cannot afford something, neither can the government." ~ Economist Thomas Sowell