Seattle taxpayers lose again: Supreme Court won’t hear city’s appeal in Brandi Kruse records case
Washington’s Supreme Court won’t hear Seattle’s appeal in Brandi Kruse’s public records win over Andrew Lewis records, leaving taxpayers with the legal bill.
The Washington State Supreme Court declined to hear Seattle’s appeal in Brandi Kruse’s public records lawsuit. (unDivided)
(unDivided)
The Washington State Supreme Court refused to rescue Seattle in a public records lawsuit the city already lost to independent journalist Brandi Kruse, leaving taxpayers to cover legal fees she estimates will reach hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Kruse, host of Undivided, sued after the city held most records tied to a pivotal 2023 vote by then-Councilmember Andrew Lewis until after he faced voters that November. The vote effectively legalized public drug use in Seattle. The Washington State Court of Appeals ruled unanimously that the city violated the Public Records Act. Seattle City Attorney Erika Evans’ office appealed anyway, and the high court declined to take the case.
The city spent three years fighting a case with no real factual dispute.
A flipped vote and a delayed request
In June 2023, Lewis provided the deciding margin when the Seattle City Council voted 5-4 to reject a proposal letting the city attorney prosecute public drug use and possession, despite earlier plans to support it.
“We wanted to know who might have gotten his ear and changed his mind, and so, you know, we filed a very narrow, very routine public records request for emails and phone calls, and then found out that we wouldn’t get the bulk of those records until after, and that was in June of 2023. We wouldn’t get the bulk of those records until after the November election of 2023, where Lewis was on the ballot, and you know we knew something was off about that. That the time frame was weird, and you know throughout the case, we were able to find out that yes, indeed, the city had failed to follow its own protocols for responding to records requests,” Kruse said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM.
Settlement offers ignored
A King County judge first ruled against Kruse. After the appellate win, she said, the city ignored her settlement offers.
“We thought, well, surely the city is going to agree to settle because we’d reached out to the city at multiple times after it became clear that the city was going to lose this case and offered to settle so we could all just move on. And they, you know, wouldn’t even respond. And I really think it’s because of my politics that they didn’t want to be seen as settling with a conservative or whatever it is. So they persisted, costing taxpayers,” she recalled.
Four justices signed the order denying review, which also directs the city to pay her attorneys for answering its petition. Jackson Maynard of the Citizen Action Defense Fund handled the case.
Kruse warned a separate lawsuit, over press passes denied to her and other conservative reporters in Olympia, could cost the public millions more.
“So I think it’s about citizens just recognizing, like, look, this is your money, and even if you don’t like me, you have to want them to follow the law and follow the Public Records Act and respect the Constitution. So until the public decides to hold them accountable, there will be no accountability,” Kruse added.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
2 Comments
“Even if you don’t like me, you have to want them to follow the law”
How did Brandi Kruse come up with this notion?
Seattle is full of liberals.
The law means nothing to them.
For Seattle liberals, laws are meant to be weaponized or ignored, depending on the need at the time.
Cant show who voted for what but they release ALL our voting info on a whim. Name address birthdate who you voted for. Way to go WA.