ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Exclusive: Seattle hit with tort claim after cop says SPD moved his old accuser into his building and two complaints followed within a month

Seattle police Lieutenant John O’Neil alleges in a new tort claim that SPD put a past accuser in his workplace, then investigated him while ignoring leaks.

Seattle police cruisers...

Seattle Police Lieutenant John O’Neil filed a new tort claim against the city on October 8. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

Seattle Police Lieutenant John O’Neil says the city ignored years of warnings that he was being racially targeted inside the department, then pointed its investigators at him instead. Now he’s filed a new tort claim.

The claim, submitted October 8 by attorney Jacob Downs, accuses the City of Seattle of harassment, discrimination and retaliation under the Washington Law Against Discrimination and the Seattle Municipal Code. It adds defamation and false light claims.

O’Neil has fought this battle before. In 2024, four female officers accused him of sexual harassment, allegations internal investigators did not substantiate. He then sued the city for discrimination and retaliation and settled for more than $200,000 last year.

Same accuser, new complaint

One of those four officers was Valerie Carson, O’Neil says. According to the claim, SPD put her right back in his orbit.

“SPD assigned Valerie Carson to the same small workplace as him despite the prior complaints and supervisors’ concerns about targeting,” the claim states. “After approximately two years without complaints against O’Neil, he received two complaints within approximately one month of Carson’s transfer to the same building.”

The first came from Sergeant Mark Grinstead, whom O’Neil had documented for alleged insubordination, the tort says. Grinstead filed a harassment and discrimination complaint on July 1. HR investigators closed it July 31, finding the allegations did not meet the basic legal threshold, it says. The claim alleges Grinstead “told others that O’Neil had problems with women and relied on earlier lawsuits and news coverage to question his fitness for his assignment.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The second came from Carson, who alleged O’Neil called the prior plaintiffs “liars” during a June meeting with the Traffic Collision Investigation Section, which O’Neil was taking over. That complaint went to a full investigation.

“O’Neil unequivocally denies calling Carson or any other former plaintiff a liar. He addressed damaging rumors affecting his ability to lead, denied accusations against him, and referred employees to public investigative records so they could evaluate the underlying information themselves,” the filing reads.

Leaks for them, silence for him?

The claim alleges a double standard. The Office of Police Accountability (OPA) previously cleared Lieutenant Lauren Truscott, another of the original accusers, after she publicly called O’Neil a “serial harasser” and “predator.”

This time, PubliCola’s Erica Barnett emailed O’Neil on August 24 reciting details of Carson’s complaint before he was formally notified it existed. Two days later, OPA reminded him he could not talk to the media without authorization.

ADVERTISEMENT

“This left him exposed to publication of damaging allegations while warning him against responding without authorization,” the claim argues.

When O’Neil complained about the apparent leak, OPA closed the matter October 2, finding no policy violation.

In an August 26 email to OPA obtained by SeattleRed, O’Neil wrote: “The system is once again being weaponized against me because I am a black male in leadership. I have done nothing wrong.”

The claim says the pending investigation threatens his shot at promotion to captain and seeks damages for emotional distress and reputational harm.

“A claim was filed with the City on or about October 8, 2026 and remains open. The City does not comment on open claims,” a spokesperson for the Office of Finance explained to The Jason Rantz Show.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

1 Comments

N
Nolan Void 1 month ago

I believe O’Neil.
His story sounds very plausible to me.