ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Ninth Circuit forces trans women into women’s spa, judge fires back with blistering dissent

The Ninth Circuit won't rehear a case forcing a WA women's spa to admit biological males, setting up a likely Supreme Court fight.

The Ninth Circuit refused to rehear Olympus Spa v. Armstrong, forcing a Christian-owned Korean spa ...

The Ninth Circuit refused to rehear Olympus Spa v. Armstrong, forcing a Christian-owned Korean spa in Bellevue to admit biological males under Washington state law. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

A federal appeals court has refused to reconsider a ruling that forces a Washington state spa to admit biological males who identify as women, setting up a likely Supreme Court battle over religious freedom and women’s privacy.

The Ninth Circuit denied a rehearing en banc in Olympus Spa v. Armstrong, leaving in place a panel decision that requires the Bellevue-based Korean spa to comply with Washington’s anti-discrimination law. The spa’s Christian owners had argued the law violated their religious beliefs and exposed their female clientele, some as young as 13, to male genitalia in an intimate nude setting.

Judge VanDyke goes straight for the jugular

Judge Lawrence VanDyke wrote the lead dissent and didn’t waste a syllable softening his view.

“This is a case about swinging d****,” VanDyke opened. “The Christian owners of Olympus Spa — a traditional Korean, women-only, nude spa — understandably don’t want them in their spa. Their female employees and female clients don’t want them in their spa either. But Washington State insists on them. And now so does the Ninth Circuit.”

VanDyke accused “woke regulators and complicit judges” of ignoring the real-world harm their rulings impose on women and girls.

Twenty-eight of his colleagues weren’t pleased. Senior Circuit Judge Margaret McKeown issued a statement calling the language “vulgar barroom talk” that “demeans this court.” Two additional judges added a one-sentence rebuke: “We are better than this.”

ADVERTISEMENT

VanDyke unloads on his critics

VanDyke fired back, writing that his colleagues display “the fastidious sensibilities of a Victorian nun when it comes to mere unpleasant words” while ignoring the government trampling on religious liberties and exposing women to male genitalia.

A separate dissent from Judge Eric Tung, joined by Judges Dorothy Nelson, Patrick Bumatay, and VanDyke, argued Washington’s law is not a neutral law of general applicability because it carves out exemptions for secular organizations while denying the same protection to a small Christian business.

The case is widely expected to head toward a Supreme Court cert petition.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

0 Comments