ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Washington Republicans demand Justice Colleen Melody recuse herself over income tax scandal

WA Republicans demand Justice Colleen Melody recuse from the income tax lawsuit, citing her ties to Gov. Ferguson and the AG's office that will defend the law.

Attorney General Nick Brown, Justice Colleen Melody, and Governor Bob Ferguson...

Justice Colleen Melody at a formal event. Washington Republicans are calling for her recusal from the state income tax case, citing ties between her appointment and the AG's office that will argue the case. (Governor Bob Ferguson's Office/Facebook)

(Governor Bob Ferguson's Office/Facebook)

Washington Republicans are demanding that a newly appointed state Supreme Court justice step aside from the looming legal fight over the state’s new 9.9% income tax, pointing to a web of connections between the justice, the governor who appointed her, and the office that both championed the law and will defend it in court.

The Washington State Republican Party issued a public call Wednesday for Justice Colleen Melody to recuse herself from any ruling on the challenges to Senate Bill 6346, citing what it describes as an undeniable conflict of interest, according to a report from The Center Square.

As internal records have already revealed, the millionaire tax was designed from the start as a test case to force the court to overturn the 1933 ruling that makes a graduated income tax unconstitutional in Washington.

The conflict behind the recusal demand

Gov. Bob Ferguson appointed Melody to the bench in January after receiving what he described as the “strongest possible recommendation” from Solicitor General Noah Purcell. Purcell works within the Washington State Office of the Attorney General, the same office that will argue the state’s case defending SB 6346 before the courts.

Records obtained by The Center Square show Purcell actively discussing with state lawmakers in December how to structure the tax so the Supreme Court would be compelled to reconsider its 1933 ruling, and how to do it while insulating the law from voter referendums. In other words, the man who pushed Ferguson to put Melody on the bench was also helping engineer the very case her court will eventually decide.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Soon, Melody will be ruling on the income tax case that the AG’s Office will be defending,” the Washington State Republican Party posted to X. “The same office that recommended her. Melody should RECUSE herself before the case begins — things are too close for comfort.”

Melody did not respond to The Center Square‘s request for comment, and her office did not indicate whether she would recuse herself.

Campaign donations deepen the conflict of interest

Washington’s Code of Judicial Conduct holds that a justice must recuse themselves when their “impartiality might reasonably be questioned.” One specific trigger is when a party to a case has contributed substantially to that justice’s judicial campaign.

According to the state Public Disclosure Commission, staff from the AG’s Office have collectively donated thousands of dollars to Melody’s 2026 reelection campaign. Purcell himself gave $500.

ADVERTISEMENT

The man who recommended her appointment, helped design the law she’ll rule on, and whose office will defend it in court also wrote a check to her campaign. The Code of Judicial Conduct exists for situations exactly like this one.

What’s at stake if Melody refuses to step aside

Rep. Jim Walsh, one of the more aggressive Republican voices on the legal fight against SB 6346, told The Center Square that the damage from Melody refusing to recuse would extend beyond the case itself. He argued it would erode confidence in the court’s independence and could make it easier for plaintiffs to shift the litigation to federal court entirely.

The lawsuit challenging the millionaire tax is currently before Klickitat County Superior Court. The case is not expected to reach the state Supreme Court before the 2026 election, in which Melody and four other justices are running to keep their seats. Seattle-based attorney Scott Edwards is the only challenger who has so far filed paperwork with the PDC to run against her.

ADVERTISEMENT

A former Democratic state Supreme Court justice has joined the legal fight to overturn the tax, and wealthy Washingtonians are already responding to the law by putting their homes on the market at a pace not seen before. MyNorthwest has more on the records showing the tax was built as a legal trap rather than a genuine revenue measure.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

0 Comments