ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Rantz Exclusive: Two openly gay Seattle cops sue the city, say SPD blocked their promotions

Two openly gay Seattle police officers are suing the City of Seattle, alleging SPD denied them promotions because of their sexual orientation and gender.

Seattle Police Department vehicles outside the West Precinct...

Detective Anna Fishel and Lt. Douglas Raguso allege the Seattle Police Department, led by Chief Shon Barnes, denied them earned promotions because they are gay. (Jason Rantz)

(Jason Rantz)

Two openly gay Seattle police officers are suing the City of Seattle, accusing a department that loves to market itself as a national model for diversity of blocking their promotions because of their sexual orientation and, in one case, her gender.

The lawsuit, filed Friday in King County Superior Court by Detective Anna Fishel and Lieutenant Douglas Raguso, alleges the Seattle Police Department repeatedly passed over two qualified officers who had each earned the top spot on their promotion lists. Fishel is a single mother and nineteen-year police veteran. Raguso, according to the filing, is only the second openly gay man to ever reach the rank of lieutenant in SPD history. Both say they were the best candidates on paper and got nothing.

The accusations are remarkable coming out of a city that has spent years branding the SPD as a progressive, inclusive employer, the same department now run by Chief Shon Barnes, who has already taken heat for ordering officers to document ICE enforcement actions or face firing. For now these remain allegations. The City has not filed a response, and no court has made any findings.

A single mom ranked first, then got offered a shift she couldn’t work

Fishel tested for sergeant in spring 2024 and climbed to number one on the promotion list by August 2025, the complaint states. She was serving as acting sergeant of SPD’s Policy Unit, applied for the permanent Policy Unit sergeant job, and ranked first after interviews. Her entire chain of command endorsed her, the lawsuit says, including her assistant chief, captain, and lieutenant.

Then, the filing alleges, Barnes told her his priority was Patrol and offered her a Third Watch patrol assignment instead, a rotating overnight schedule. As the solo caregiver for her school-aged daughter, with a wife living outside the country, Fishel says she told the chief she could not make the shifts work financially or logistically. On December 31, 2025, according to the complaint, a straight male officer who had applied for the same Policy Unit job was pulled off Patrol and dropped into the position she had ranked first for.

ADVERTISEMENT

“The City’s continued assertion that Patrol is the only available promotional option fails to acknowledge and accommodate Ms. Fishel’s obligations as a mother. Ms. Fishel’s gender and sexual orientation have each been substantial factors in the City’s failure to promote her to a non-Patrol Sergeant position,” the complaint alleges.

A year at number one, and never made captain

Raguso’s story runs parallel. He tested for captain in early 2023 and, after others were promoted, sat at number one on the captain roster for more than twelve months, the lawsuit alleges. The roster was frozen, unfrozen, and frozen again, the complaint contends, while a straight officer leapfrogged him into the top spot and got promoted. Within roughly two weeks of Raguso being transferred out of the East Precinct, four lieutenants were promoted to captain into jobs the suit says were open the entire time he led the roster.

ADVERTISEMENT

When he asked Deputy Chief Yvonne Underwood why, the filing offers her explanation.

“Deputy Chief Underwood stated that Command Staff did not promote Mr. Raguso in the last round because they had to ‘save’ slots. Deputy Chief Underwood did not elaborate on what she meant by needing to ‘save’ slots,” the lawsuit argues.

The complaint also describes a meeting that went sideways fast.

“During the meeting, Chief Barnes asked Mr. Raguso if he had ‘leaked’ the planned appointment of Mike Tietjen. The meeting became so contentious that Mr. Raguso left it in tears,” according to the complaint.

The Tietjen appointment was its own firestorm. Around the same time Raguso was moved out of the East Precinct, Barnes promoted Tietjen to captain and put him in charge of the precinct covering Capitol Hill, despite a 2020 disciplinary record that, as PubliCola reported, included comparing scattering protesters to “cockroaches” and a written reprimand tied to an incident in which officers reportedly harassed a trans woman. Barnes pulled Tietjen from the role weeks later, according to the complaint, and handed the precinct to Captain Jim Britt instead.

ADVERTISEMENT

Had he gotten the job, the suit notes, Raguso would have been the first openly gay male captain in SPD history.

Is patrol really the rule, or just a convenient wall?

The City’s stated rationale, per the complaint, is that newly minted sergeants should spend six months to a year in Patrol to build experience. That tracks with how Barnes talks publicly, having called patrol the backbone of policing when pushing his staffing goals. Under SPD’s own structure, every officer starts in patrol before testing for sergeant.

Here’s the problem the plaintiffs raise. They allege there is no actual written “patrol requirement” policy in the department, in Human Resources rules, or in the Public Safety Civil Service rules, and that the City has promoted plenty of other people to sergeant in non-Patrol roles and in place. If the rule is real, the suit asks, why does it keep bending for everyone except the gay single mom and the gay lieutenant?

ADVERTISEMENT

It’s a tidy bit of irony for a city that lectures the rest of the country about equity, and for a chief whose tenure has already generated questions over referral bonuses he collected for hiring his own deputies and taxpayer-funded travel and sponsorships.

What the officers want

Fishel and Raguso, represented by the Terrell Marshall Law Group, are suing under the Washington Law Against Discrimination and the Seattle Fair Employment Practices Ordinance. They are seeking back pay, lost pension and retirement benefits, damages for emotional harm, and an injunction placing them in the positions they say they earned.

The City of Seattle has not commented on the allegations. But the optics are already brutal.

The progressive establishment that built its identity around inclusion is now defending itself against a discrimination claim brought by two of its own openly gay officers, and the only thing standing between them and a promotion, they say, is a patrol rule nobody can seem to find in writing.

ADVERTISEMENT

SPD did not respond to a Sunday request seeking comment. The city does not typically offer comment on active litigation.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

4 Comments

J
Jason Pantz 6 months ago

These people think if they don’t rise to the top as soon as they apply it’s discrimination. The entitlement of the protected class. In reality they probably weren’t even qualified for the job to begin with.

K
Krista Kirkman 6 months ago

If you want a job you accept whatever shift your given.

T
T B 6 months ago

Could it possibly be there were other qualified candidates? Soon we’ll read the two settled with the city for an undisclosed amount of money and resigned. Too bad I just retired, like most, instead of trying to get more money for something.