ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Federal court removes gender-affirming requirements for Oregon foster parents in major win for religious liberty

A federal court has removed Oregon's requirement for foster parents to affirm children's gender identity in what is a significant win for religious liberty.

Photo: Court gavel....

A federal court ruling delivered a major religious liberty victory for foster parents in Oregon. (File Photo from Pexels)

(File Photo from Pexels)

Foster and adoptive parents just achieved a significant win for religious liberty in the state of the Oregon as they are no longer required to commit to affirming a child’s LGBTQ+ identity.

A recent federal court ruling has narrowed child welfare officials’ ability to determine inclusive placements and removed the gender-affirming requirement for caregivers. The ruling comes after officials with the Oregon Department of Human Services and the conservative legal group Alliance Defending Freedom reached an agreement in federal court to allow a widowed mother of five named Jessica Bates to apply to be an adoptive parent for children in the state’s custody.

How we got here

Bates desired to give her children more siblings, but refused to take a child to a Pride parade, nor would she allow them to receive cross-sex hormones. After she filed a lawsuit, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals struck down an Oregon rule last year on free speech grounds that mandated parents to “respect, accept, and support” the children’s sexual orientation, gender identity, and gender expression.

“Oregon’s policy both restricts and compels speech based on content and viewpoint in the areas of sexual orientation, gender identity, and gender expression,” said the majority opinion. “Strict scrutiny applies to Bates’s free exercise claim because Oregon’s policy burdens Bates’s religious exercise and is neither neutral nor generally applicable.”

The 9th Circuit then sent the case back to the district court for further review, which resulted in this agreement.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Every child deserves a loving home, and children suffer when the government excludes people of faith from foster care because of the state’s own ideological crusade,” said ADF senior counsel Johannes Widmalm-Delphonse in a statement. “Oregon officials turned Jessica away just because of her common-sense belief that parents should help children become comfortable with who they are instead of pushing them down a path of confusion and medicalization.”

Oregon may still try to get around the ruling

Gender ideologues in The Beaver State hammered the decision, claiming it allows parents to discriminate against a marginalized group.

“LGBTQ+ youth in foster care deserve safe and affirming homes. Putting children’s interests first means respecting who they are,” said Kyndall Mason, executive director of Basic Rights Oregon. “Basic Rights Oregon will continue working to make Oregon a safe place for young queer and trans people, and that includes those in foster care.”

ADVERTISEMENT

People of faith in Oregon should stay on their toes though, as the state appears to already be scheming to circumvent the ruling. Spokesperson for the human services department Jake Sunderland said the agency will continue to place children “with foster and adoptive parents who are able and willing to support and affirm them.”

“This judgment does not prevent ODHS from deciding a child’s placement based on their specific needs and a foster or adoptive parent’s ability or willingness to meet them, including the child’s sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression,” Sunderland added. “ODHS has updated its rules and policies to comply with this judgment, and we continue to prioritize child-specific safety needs so that all children and young people in foster care have access to a safe and supportive environment.”

The Trump Administration is keeping an eye on Oregon

Foster parents can be encouraged by the fact that they have back from the federal government. Oregon’s LGBTQ+ foster policy caught the eye of the Trump Administration, which launched an investigation into it last year.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Administration has yet to take legal action or withhold funding from Oregon, but it is taking a victory lap after this most recent court ruling.

“Children in foster care need loving families, not government tests for ideological alignment,” said Alex Adams, assistant secretary for the Administration of Children and Families under the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. “Oregon’s decision to no longer require foster parents to affirm beliefs that are inconsistent with their sincerely held beliefs is aligned with ACF’s position and federal law.”

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Jackson Meyer Producer, The Jason Rantz Show

Born and raised in Issaquah, Jackson is a lifelong Washingtonian. He is an avid sports fan, particularly of baseball, which he played at the varsity level in High School. He worked at the Seattle-based conservative think tank Discovery Institute for… Read more

Comments

0 Comments