ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Appeals court sides with Trump over subpoena of Washington transgender care provider

A divided 9th Circuit revived a Justice Department subpoena against a Washington provider treating transgender minors, reversing a lower court ruling.

9th Circuit Court of Appeals...

A federal appeals court has revived the Justice Department's subpoena of a Washington provider that treats transgender minors. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

(Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

A divided federal appeals court ruled that President Donald Trump’s goal of ending so-called “gender-affirming care” is a legitimate law enforcement priority, reviving a Justice Department subpoena against a Washington state provider that treats transgender minors. The 2-1 decision from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals is the first appellate ruling to go the administration’s way after a string of losses in lower courts.

The Justice Department announced last year that it had issued more than 20 subpoenas to doctors and clinics offering gender-affirming care as part of a health care fraud investigation, according to the Associated Press. Federal judges tossed out many of them, calling the demands an attempt to scare providers into shutting down. The 9th Circuit panel rejected that reasoning and said a president is entitled to align the Justice Department’s enforcement priorities with his own policy agenda.

The ruling reverses a lower court decision that had quashed the subpoena against telemedicine provider QueerDoc and sends the case back to district court.

What federal investigators want from the Washington provider

The subpoena seeks QueerDoc’s personnel files, billing documents, communications with drug manufacturers and records of patients prescribed puberty blockers or hormone therapy, among other material, according to the 9th Circuit decision. The Justice Department has said it has reason to believe the company may be misleading people about those drugs.

ADVERTISEMENT

QueerDoc still has legal arguments left. The company has claimed the subpoena sweeps too widely and is burdensome, and the district court will now take up those questions. American Civil Liberties Union attorney Adrien Leavitt, who represents the provider, said the fight continues.

“We’re ready to continue defending one of the most fundamental principles of healthcare: every patient’s right to confidential medical care,” Leavitt said in a statement.

Judges note the science is unsettled

Judge Carlos Bea wrote for the majority that the efficacy and long-term risks of the treatments are uncertain, and that the administration could defend its opposition on ethical or philosophical grounds. Bea, a nominee of President George W. Bush, was joined by Trump nominee Daniel Bress.

“Every President has law enforcement priorities, just as every President has signature policies (often, the former are components of the latter),” Bea wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

Washington law lets minors as young as 13 access gender-affirming care without parental consent, and Washington Democrats have written protections for the treatments into statute. The Trump administration has taken the opposite approach, with federal rules threatening to strip Medicare and Medicaid funding from hospitals in Washington and Oregon that keep providing the interventions to minors. Seattle Children’s Hospital already paused some surgeries on minors under that pressure.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments