Federal judge dismisses lawsuit against Idaho ban on vaccine, medical treatment requirements for daycares in win for medical freedom
A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit against an Idaho law that prevents daycares from requiring vaccines and other medical treatments.
A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit against Idaho's ban on daycares requiring vaccines and medical treatments (MyNorthwest photo)
(MyNorthwest photo)
A federal judge in Idaho dismissed a lawsuit brought by a Boise daycare and parents that sought to block the state’s Medical Freedom Act, which prohibits daycares from requiring vaccines or medical treatment.
The lawsuit claimed the law was unconstitutionally vague and could ban basic hygienic practices such as handwashing and sending sick kids home.
The judge dismissed the ambiguity argument
Chief U.S. District Judge for the District of Idaho Amanda K. Brailsford wasn’t buying the daycare’s argument though and granted Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador’s request to dismiss the lawsuit.
“The (Idaho Medical Freedom Act) plainly and unambiguously sets out a standard of prohibited conduct that gives a person of ordinary intelligence fair notice of what is prohibited,” wrote Brailsford.
Brailsford also agreed with Labrador’s interpretation of the legislation, writing that the law’s definition of “medical interventions” refer to health practices that “medical in nature.”
“The Court agrees with the AG that Le Soleil is free to promote its beliefs and values about public health and vaccinations,” Brailsford added. “The only thing the (Idaho Medical Freedom Act) prevents is Le Soleil requiring that only vaccinated students hear those values.”
A win for parents’ rights
The ruling upholds Idaho’s ban on daycares, businesses, governments, and schools from requiring vaccines or “medical interventions,” which the law defines as “a medical procedure, treatment, device, drug injection, medication, or medical action taken to diagnose, prevent, or cure a disease or alter the health or biological function of a person.”
Labrador hailed the decision as a win for medical freedom and parents’ rights.
“Parents make medical decisions for their children. A daycare does not,” he said in a statement. “The Legislature protected that choice in the Medical Freedom Act, and the court upheld it. Daycares can tell parents what they believe about vaccines and health, but they cannot turn a child away because of a parent’s medical decision. That decision belongs to families, and I’m pleased the court agreed.”
However, an attorney for the daycare and parents Andrea Carone says the fight might not be over yet as they are considering appealing the ruling 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
“Our clients are obviously disappointed by the district court’s ruling and the narrow manner in which it interpreted the right at issue,” Carone said in a statement. “The Idaho Medical Freedom Act places parents like our individual clients and daycares like Le Soleil in the untenable position of being unable to take reasonable steps to protect their children or children in their care from childhood diseases that vaccines shield against. This is a clear public health issue that we must rely, in the near term, on the Idaho Legislature to address and correct.”
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
0 Comments