ADVERTISEMENT

ENERGY

‘We chased away the developer’: Democrat lambasts activists for pushing out major solar project in Eastern Washington

Avangrid has withdrawn its Badger Mountain solar permit after years of tribal objections and regulatory delays, a case study in WA's permitting mess.

Badger Mountain...

Avangrid withdrew its permit application for a solar project on Badger Mountain in Eastern Washington after years of delays and tribal objections. (National Park Service)

(National Park Service)

Avangrid has walked away from its Badger Mountain solar project in Eastern Washington, ending a five-year fight that became a case study in how tangled the state’s permitting process has gotten for the developers it claims to want.

The company filed to fully withdraw its permit application after years of delays, according to reporting from ProPublica and High Country News. The state’s permitting authority council formally announced the withdrawal, saying it was closing out financial arrangements and notifying partners, and referred further questions to Avangrid. The company has not explained its reasoning.

The project’s collapse followed a 2024 investigation that found Avangrid and a consultant it hired, Tetra Tech, had left key archaeological and cultural information out of a state-mandated review of the Badger Mountain site. A state archaeologist had warned that the project would threaten historic sites and ongoing ceremonial use of the land. The Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation and the Confederated Tribes and Bands of the Yakama Nation hold protected rights to gather food and practice traditions on the mountain, and a Colville Tribal Business Council member told reporters at the time the project would wipe out roughly half the area’s root vegetable harvest.

Tribal objections, a pause, then a full withdrawal

After that reporting came out, members of the Wenatchi-P’squosa, one of the 12 Confederated Colville Tribes, held a demonstration on Badger Mountain. They said they support renewable energy but oppose building it on culturally significant land. Avangrid paused development to reconsider the tribal input and public pushback.

ADVERTISEMENT

At a July meeting of the state’s permitting authority council, an Avangrid senior director asked for the pause to continue, citing anticipated construction delays affecting the power grid. Council chair Kurt Beckett dismissed the environmental and cultural concerns as “noise” at that meeting, though he also said tribal objections should factor into the state’s permitting decision. Five days later, Avangrid asked to withdraw the project entirely.

A Democrat points to the regulatory climate

Former state Sen. Reuven Carlyle raised the withdrawal on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM and used it as a warning sign for Washington’s business climate rather than a story about any single project. Carlyle did not address the tribal cultural resource dispute directly. His argument was about what five years of permitting limbo does to developers regardless of the underlying reason.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Today they announced that this giant solar project in Central Washington, which was very well thought out, that the developer pulled out after five years of permitting headaches, and there was incredible high value of grid modernization and renewable energy coming from that, and we chased away the developer, the private sector developer, because of so much bureaucracy and complexity,” Carlyle said.

Carlyle, who spent 14 years in the state Senate, argued that Washington cannot claim to be serious about clean energy while making it functionally impossible for private developers to build it.

“You can’t be a Democrat that cares about climate change the way I am, and not have the humility and the honesty to acknowledge that we, as a state, have categorically failed to partner with the private sector to generate the kind of investments that we need to build to build our future,” Carlyle said.

ADVERTISEMENT

The state Department of Natural Resources, which owns the public parcel on Badger Mountain, said it has not received any other proposals to develop the site for clean energy. Whatever combination of tribal objections and regulatory drag actually killed the project, Washington is left with five years of permitting work, a canceled solar farm, and no clear plan for what happens to Badger Mountain next.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

3 Comments

R
RODNEY FOSBACK 4 months ago

This is good news for Eastern Washington. Windmills that litter the landscape and solar farms that smother the land should be built West of the Cascades, where the people love them, or not at all.

L
Lori D. Stach 4 months ago

On our road trip to Texas last year, we saw acres and acres and acres of solar panels.
I did a dive down the rabbit hole and discovered that those "solar farms" produce less (I'm pretty certain) than 1%-3% of total power for Los Angeles city limits. The population of LA city limits is estimated to be 3.6-3.7 Million people! And that's only if those panels are working and the sun is shining!
IMHO, it's an incredible waste of $$$$ for the expected financial return.
No one that I know wants "solar farms" adding to garbage of the current "wind farms"!
They're both a blight on our land as well as the Tribes land!!
I am thrilled that they halted the plan!!

W
Waldo62 . 4 months ago

Good riddance. Get rid of the wind farms too. Blight! Regional 'new gen' nuclear is the way.