ADVERTISEMENT

LEGAL

Tacoma therapist gets second shot at Washington’s counseling censorship law

A federal judge reopened Brian Tingley's free speech lawsuit against Washington's counseling ban after the Supreme Court's 8-1 ruling in Chiles v. Salazar.

Brian Tingley...

A federal judge reopened a Tacoma therapist's free speech challenge to Washington's counseling law after a Supreme Court ruling in a similar Colorado case. (Alliance Defending Freedom)

(Alliance Defending Freedom)

A federal judge has revived Tacoma therapist Brian Tingley’s free speech lawsuit against Washington’s counseling censorship law, five years after the courts threw the case out and told him he had no standing to complain.

U.S. District Judge Tiffany Cartwright reopened the first count of the suit, Tingley’s free speech claim, in a July 30 minute entry issued after a hearing on his motion. The decision follows the U.S. Supreme Court’s 8-1 ruling in March in Chiles v. Salazar, which held that a nearly identical Colorado law regulated speech based on viewpoint and must survive strict scrutiny. Washington Attorney General Nick Brown fought the request, and Equal Rights Washington intervened on the state’s side.

Tingley sued in 2021 over a 2018 statute that added so-called conversion therapy to the list of offenses that can strip a counselor of his license. The district court dismissed him, the 9th Circuit affirmed, and the Supreme Court declined to hear the appeal in 2023. Then the justices took up an ADF case out of Colorado and blew a hole in the reasoning Washington had been relying on.

What the state actually banned

Johannes Widmalm-Delphonse, senior counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom, argued the motion in court last week and walked through what his client does for a living.

“Brian Tingley, as you mentioned, has spent over 20 years as a licensed marriage and family therapist. He provides counseling to adults and minors, and he just does it through conversations,” Widmalm-Delphonse said on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “So this Washington law was about enforcing the government’s viewpoint, and that all these counselors must promote gender ideology, and they cannot just have the conversations to pursue goals consistent with the client’s Christian faith.”

ADVERTISEMENT

The state calls it conversion therapy. Widmalm-Delphonse rejected the label.

“That sort of pejorative term is very unhelpful because it sort of sweeps up aversive techniques, other types of physical interventions that counselors have long ago abandoned, and which Mr. Tingley doesn’t provide at all,” he noted. “Brian Tingley just provides voluntary conversations, and it’s always consistent with the client’s own goals.”

He also pointed to what happens to kids who never get the conversation at all.

“Particularly for gender, children or adolescents who are struggling with gender dysphoria, most of them will achieve comfort with their body if they’re not pushed into sort of the medicalization route,” Widmalm-Delphonse argued. “If they don’t start puberty blockers, if they don’t start hormones, most of them will achieve that comfort with their body. But of course, the point here is that no matter what the client’s goals are, counselors should be able to help them so long as they’re respecting the client’s self-determination, which Brian Tingley always does.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Washington still thinks it can win

Brown’s office told the court the law survives strict scrutiny because it addresses a compelling interest and is the least restrictive alternative available. Widmalm-Delphonse does not buy it, and he cited some history.

“When you are infringing on free speech rights, government must show a compelling interest, and that it used the narrowest, least restrictive means to achieve that interest,” he said. “Now Washington seems to believe that it can meet that standard, but I would point out that the Supreme Court has never, in its entire history, upheld a law that was viewpoint discriminatory under that standard. So we think it’s a steep hill for Washington to climb.”

He added that the demand for counselors is not theoretical. “There’s an epidemic of mental health deterioration among adolescents, and they should be able to seek the counselors who they feel most comfortable with to pursue their own goals,” Widmalm-Delphonse said.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what will happen next

The reopening is not the end of anything. ADF has a preliminary injunction motion pending, and the state gets to decide how hard it wants to litigate a position the Supreme Court already rejected in a case brought by the same law firm.

“Right now there’s a briefing schedule on a preliminary injunction, so we’re seeking protection from the court right away,” Widmalm-Delphonse told listeners. “We’ll see whether Washington actually chooses to fight the preliminary injunction. It could be months. It could be years.”

Washington has spent years insisting its version of this law regulates conduct rather than speech. That argument died in March. Whether Brown accepts it or spends more taxpayer money finding out is now the only open question, and it comes as the state absorbs other federal losses on gender policy.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Comments

1 Comments

M
Mama San 3 months ago

So this is all about gender dysphoria? And what is the problem with counseling kids to wait and see if they will be able to become comfortable with their own body sometimes during the puberty phase?