ADVERTISEMENT

EDUCATION

UW professors suggest their own colleagues may be teaching students that shouting down speakers is acceptable

Emails obtained by Seattle Red show University of Washington faculty asking whether professors helped create students who justify shouting down speakers.

Masked activists and pro-Palestinian protestors took over and barricaded themselves in the universi...

The University of Washington placed 260th out of 261 schools in FIRE's 2027 College Free Speech Rankings. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

University of Washington professors are quietly questioning whether their own colleagues helped produce students who believe shouting down a speaker, or even using violence, can be justified.

The debate unfolded on the mailing list for UW’s chapter of the American Association of University Professors (AAUP), in emails obtained by Seattle Red, after the university placed 260th out of 261 schools in the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression’s 2027 College Free Speech Rankings. FIRE found 79 percent of surveyed UW students believe shouting down a speaker is acceptable at least in rare cases, and 41 percent said the same about using violence to stop someone from speaking.

Seattle Red reported last week that UW earned its sixth consecutive F for its speech climate. FIRE also placed the school in the bottom 25 nationally for disruptive conduct.

The faculty reaction was not a defense of the university. Professors turned the question on themselves.

UW professors start looking at themselves

Professor Emeritus Arthur Nowell highlighted the 41 percent figure and told colleagues the problem could not be handed off to administrators.

“What concerns me most isn’t any single incident but the trend line in student attitudes: a large minority now see disruption, and even violence, as legitimate tools for shutting down speech they disagree with, rather than engaging it,” Nowell wrote.

He then asked faculty what instructors could do to encourage respectful disagreement and genuine discussion instead of avoidance or confrontation.

“I don’t think this is a problem administration can fix on its own, it’s something we model and teach in our own classrooms and advising relationships,” Nowell added.

ADVERTISEMENT

Sociology Professor Emeritus Paul Burstein went further and pointed at the faculty itself.

“I would be happy to be proven wrong, but my guess is that the problematic views of students come about in part because such views are promoted by some faculty,” Burstein wrote.

A chapter with a very different public record

The exchange is notable because the UW AAUP chapter has publicly defended DEI policies, attacked the Trump administration, and backed faculty caught up in contentious Israel-related disputes. Seattle Red previously reported on the chapter defending Professor Aria Fani after UW removed him from a leadership post over emails about the Iran conflict.

Daniel McConnell, a UW academic adviser, pushed the same argument toward campus culture.

“You have the answer right there. Instead of creating ‘safe’ spaces for students, help students sit with, work through, and emerge from difficult conversations,” McConnell responded.

ADVERTISEMENT

FIRE documented multiple attempted disruptions and canceled speaking events at UW over the past year. University leaders have treated the rankings as an administrative failure. The emails show at least some faculty now suspect the problem starts in their own classrooms.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

1 Comments

R
Roger Anderson 2 months ago

Graduated from UW way back in 1980 and was as proud as could be. Now it's embarrassing to admit I ever set foot on the campus.