Rantz: The Seattle Times says Washington’s Supreme Court needs change, then backs the candidate who makes it worse
The Seattle Times endorsed Jaime Hawk for Washington Supreme Court Position 3 while admitting she wouldn't change the court. Its stated reason was national politics.
The Seattle Times editorial board endorsed Jaime Hawk over David Stevens in the Washington Supreme Court Position 3 race. (Hawk and Stevens campaign websites)
(Hawk and Stevens campaign websites)
The Seattle Times editorial board unsurprisingly endorsed far-left Jaime Hawk for Washington Supreme Court Position 3 after conceding she would probably change nothing about the court it says needs changing. The reason the board gave was not Hawk’s record, her rulings, or her temperament. It was the U.S. Supreme Court, about 2,700 miles from Olympia.
Washington voters are apparently supposed to treat a Mason County versus King County judicial race as a protest vote against Clarence Thomas. Or something.
Position 3 is open because Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis declined to seek reelection, one of five seats on the ballot this November. Hawk is a King County Superior Court judge and a former attorney for the ACLU of Washington. Her opponent is Mason County Superior Court Judge David Stevens, a former public defender who told me in February that the current court decides cases by preferred outcome rather than by the constitution. The board’s primary choice, Court of Appeals Judge Mike Diaz, finished third and is off the ballot.
So the board had to pick between two people it says do not excite it. What it wrote to explain the pick is more revealing than the pick itself. It really makes no sense.
The board’s reasoning doesn’t really make sense
Before endorsing Hawk, the editorial argues that a judicial election in Washington cannot be separated from the fights consuming the U.S. Supreme Court. “That is a pity, but it is why we now endorse Hawk,” it writes.
The board is not claiming Hawk is the better judge. It is claiming that Samuel Alito and Thomas dissented from a recent U.S. Supreme Court order on mail-in voting, that Stevens has praised those two justices, and that voters should react accordingly. An open seat on Washington’s highest court, which decides our tax cases, our criminal law, and our constitutional questions, gets treated as a referendum on someone else’s bench.
Nobody in Shelton or Aberdeen is affected by what Thomas thinks the way they are affected by what the nine justices in Olympia do.
Partisanship is a problem until it is convenient
The editorial does acknowledge the ugliest moment of this campaign. At the state Democratic convention last summer, Hawk’s partner, Democratic state Treasurer Mike Pellicciotti, led the delegates in a call-and-response cheer for her, with half the room shouting “Judge” and the other half shouting “Hawk.” The board correctly notes that this sort of display in a nonpartisan judicial contest is rare for good reason.
Then it lets her off the hook.
“The candidate does not appear to have orchestrated the incident of her enthusiastic partner,” it writes, though there was a commercial doing the exact same stunt, but with Governor Bob Ferguson. The editorial board pretends the ad, which featured Hawk, doesn’t exist because then they wouldn’t be able to feign outrage over the delegates event. These are not serious people.
Stevens never held a partisan rally. He answered a question on my show about which justices he admires and the Times cited it as apparently disqualifying in their endorsement of Hawk. One of those things is partisanship and the other is a job interview, and only one of them cost a candidate the endorsement. Sort of. The real issue is that the editorial board will almost always support the liberal voice.
What Stevens actually said
The board described Stevens as perplexing on judicial philosophy. Here is the full exchange it was working from.
“I think it’s important to actually know what justices a potential Supreme Court Justice would want to emulate,” Stevens told me on The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM. “So my favorite would be Clarence Thomas, second would be Antonin Scalia and Supreme Court Justice Alito … those are judges I really like and follow and I’d hope to be in a similar vein as them.”
When I asked whether naming those three would get him typecast, he did not retreat.
“Well, if adhering to the United States Constitution, the Washington State Supreme constitution, is conservative, then I guess I am,” Stevens answered. “I don’t believe that that’s a conservative position. I think that’s the way judges should interpret the law.”
He went further on what the document requires.
“I believe that, you know, they have to follow the state constitution, which is very clear on certain subjects, like taxation, treating people equally, things of that nature,” he said.
On how the current majority got there, he pointed at the governor’s office. “So I think you need to look at how these people get on the state Supreme Court,” Stevens added. “The majority of them were actually appointed by governors.”
There is nothing perplexing in any of that. A voter can disagree with every word, but the man told you exactly what he believes and why. That is more than the board got from his opponent.
Mason County pays the bill King County writes
The most concrete disagreement in this race barely registered in the endorsement. In 2025 the Washington Supreme Court slashed public defender caseload limits to 47 felonies or 120 misdemeanors a year, down from 150 and 400. Counties either triple their defense bar or watch prosecutors file a fraction of the cases they file now. The county association said flatly that the standards are unreachable at current funding.
Hawk approved of the mandate. Stevens, who actually presided over criminal dockets in Mason County and worked as a public defender himself, said the order was issued without serious regard for what it does to counties like his. He also sided with retired Justice Barbara Madsen against the court’s handling of education funding.
The board wrote all of this down. It acknowledged that rural counties warn the unfunded mandate could wreck their public safety budgets. It acknowledged that Hawk approved anyway, and admitted what that means. “Which was not a great signal that she would bring needed change,” it said before it endorsed her and expressed hope that she might someday develop an independent voice.
That is the whole argument. The candidate who has already demonstrated independence from this court is dangerous because of who he admires on the U.S. Supreme Court. The candidate who has demonstrated none is worth a gamble because the board likes where she started. Editorial boards are allowed to prefer a liberal to a conservative. They should just say so instead of dressing it up as a complaint about partisanship.
Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.






Comments
1 Comments
it's insanity to keep voting for these leftist whack jobs becasue of TDS...its INSANE...wake up people...