ADVERTISEMENT

EDUCATION

‘I have never seen anything like this’: In rare rebuke, Seattle superintendent blasts teachers union with receipts

Seattle Public Schools Superintendent Ben Shuldiner published teacher salary figures, a bargaining timeline, and a regressive bargaining claim against SEA.

Seattle Public Schools Superintendent Ben Shuldiner...

Seattle Public Schools Superintendent Ben Shuldiner used his weekly community newsletter to publish the district's bargaining record with the Seattle Education Association days before the scheduled first day of school. (Seattle Public Schools)

(Seattle Public Schools)

Seattle Public Schools Superintendent Ben Shuldiner spent Sunday publishing the district’s side of contract talks in granular detail, naming the Seattle Education Association (SEA), printing teacher salary figures down to the dollar, and accusing the union of regressive bargaining two days before roughly 50,000 students are scheduled to return to class.

The message went out as the superintendent’s weekly community newsletter and ran eight pages. Superintendents in this region do not do this.

The customary move is a statement about good faith and respect for labor partners, which is what Shuldiner himself put out earlier in the week. Washington’s education leaders are not generally shy about public messaging, as state Superintendent Chris Reykdal demonstrated with his own Facebook commentary this month, but aiming it at organized labor is another thing entirely. What he published August 30 came with dates, dollar amounts, a bargaining timeline, and a claim that the union’s most recent conduct at the table crossed a legal line.

Why the superintendent decided to talk

The district posted portions of its latest offer and its rationale online the day before. Shuldiner opened by addressing why the district had stayed quiet for months while SEA talked. School district attorneys, he noted, tend to warn against saying anything that could be construed as bargaining in public or direct dealing.

ADVERTISEMENT

“However, as many folks know, by not addressing things in public, only one side is being heard from. I have negotiated many contracts in my time, and I have never responded publicly about any of them. But that is also because I have never had a union or association share so publicly as SEA does. That is certainly their prerogative. I would never tell a union how to negotiate,” Shuldiner wrote.

He also documented how long it took to get SEA into a room. The district asked to begin bargaining on March 6.

“We were willing and ready to meet anytime, anywhere. However, SEA responded to our multiple entreaties with requests for data and did not commit to an actual meeting until June 25th, almost four full months since we initially reached out,” he wrote.

Shuldiner noted that the union has occasionally shared its opinions of district proposals, once with a poop emoji, which he suggested is not standard practice. He said most of SEA’s correspondence had been fine until last week.

ADVERTISEMENT

The salary numbers the district is spotlighting

Shuldiner walked through the offer using the district’s non-union employees as the benchmark.

On August 26, the board approved a raise for non-represented staff, meaning coordinators and managers, of 1.73% paired with two furlough days, which he calculated as a net raise of less than 1% for the 2026-2027 school year. Many of those employees receive no overtime, no stipends, and no Time, Responsibility and Incentive (TRI) pay.

He then broke down why the district cannot pass through the state’s full inflation adjustment. State IPD (implicit price deflator) is 2.6% this year, but Seattle receives roughly two-thirds of that because the state funds districts through a prototypical model rather than actual staffing.

“So, this means anytime a staff member asks for and receives the full IPD percentage, they are really getting much more than the State gives us. This is not a pass through; it is an added burden on an already burdened budget. And you might think, that 0.87% isn’t a big deal, but it represents millions of dollars for the district writ large,” Shuldiner wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

The offer on the table for SEA is considerably larger than what managers got.

“Nonetheless, we have offered SEA a minimum of an 8.8% raise over three years, with no furlough days. This 8.8% is based on the expected IPD rate for the 2027-2028 and the 2028-2029 school years. We have also promised that if IPD comes in higher, we will adjust, and if IPD comes in lower, we will let SEA members keep the extra, hence 8.8% being the minimum,” he wrote.

What Seattle teachers actually make

The section certain to get the most attention is the one where Shuldiner published compensation for the most heavily populated salary line in the district. Those 1,060 teachers have a base wage of $118,716 for 180 days of work, plus $3,298 for five extra contractual days, $2,638 for four tech days, and $17,932 for TRI days. Total wage, $142,584, before benefits, retirement, stipends, or extra hours.

He described what TRI pay already covers, including preparation before and during the school year, communicating with parents, preparing and replacing materials, PTSA and committee work, IEP and Section 504 meetings, and end-of-year grading paperwork.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I have never seen anything like this outside of Washington. I am not saying the teachers don’t deserve this. I am only saying I wish I got this when I was a teacher. I also want to make sure that the community knows that this is already in their contract,” Shuldiner wrote.

Under the current collective bargaining agreement, TRI days are assumed to be worked. There is no verification and no paperwork. As he put it, the TRI is in the check.

A special education proposal that got a one-line answer

Shuldiner, who in his first six months has also weighed in on district questions including classroom cellphone rules, said he received well over 500 emails on the district’s special education proposal, most of them apparently form letters. He argued the district’s model treats special education as a place rather than a service, separating students to the point that many children with individualized education program (IEPs) cannot attend their neighborhood school. The district’s proposal would lower staff-to-student ratios for a majority of special education students and add behavioral support for teachers.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We have proposed many different models with changes along the way based on feedback from SEA. However, even after meeting with SEA for many hours, over the last week, SEA has told us that they can’t respond in a formal way, because it is too hard or too difficult. In fact, their latest proposal to us just reads: ‘Special Education.’ When we asked them to explain, they said they worked really really hard, (which I know is true) but just couldn’t come up with anything to address the issues we discussed,” Shuldiner wrote.

The district’s package also includes six additional psychologists, a full social worker or counselor at every school over 350 students, bringing contracted behavior analysts in house and onto SEA’s membership rolls, VEBA accounts, and a training day for more than 1,500 paraeducators and office staff worth close to a 0.5% annual raise. Weekly staff meetings would drop to three per month.

ADVERTISEMENT

Why the district called in a mediator

SEA delivered a comprehensive proposal on August 24. The district responded within 24 hours, agreeing to some items and rejecting others, then heard nothing Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday. After nearly a week of silence, the district countered its own offer and added money to the salary scale.

“And what did the union do? They gave us a comprehensive proposal that was millions more than their original proposal. They added numerous FTE, millions of dollars of extra pay, days, and time. When we received this, we asked for clarification around all of these new to their Monday comprehensive proposal. They admitted that it was new to the comprehensive proposal and that in fact they knew it cost millions of dollars more,” Shuldiner wrote.

The district called the Public Employment Relations Commission and requested a mediator, who was assigned the following morning. Shuldiner said the district did not storm off, and that continuing to negotiate from the union’s new document would have meant accepting it as the starting point. All of it, he noted, is happening against a budget he described as terrible and currently leading the district toward insolvency.

ADVERTISEMENT

Questionable leadership at SEA

SEA members voted 91.2% to authorize a strike on August 26, with just under 2,000 ballots cast out of roughly 6,000 represented employees. The union has said it wants smaller class sizes, more special education staffing, and raises above inflation. A walkout would begin Wednesday, the district’s scheduled first day.

The union is also operating under leadership questions of its own.

SEA elected president Ibijoke Idowu while she was on paid administrative leave amid an investigation into allegations she physically harmed a special-needs student, a race the union certified anyway. That is the organization now deciding whether 50,000 Seattle children start school on time.

Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on weekday afternoons from 3 p.m. – 7 p.m. on Seattle Red on 770 AM (HD Radio 97.3 FM HD-Channel 3). Subscribe to the podcast here. Follow Jason Rantz on X, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook.

Jason Rantz Talk Show Host and Columnist at Seattle Red

Jason Rantz hosts The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red 770 AM weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m.

Comments

3 Comments

J
Jake Morningwood 3 months ago

At least Seattle students have some of the highest test scores in the country. 😂😂😂

S
Steve Seberson 3 months ago

Student performance is also connected to a society and a culture that is not focused on excellence. Students, for the most part, struggle with the ability and stamina to focus and concentrate for extended periods of learning time. Parents and schools must eliminate screen time at home and at school for most of the day.

E
Eric Schmeric 3 months ago

Seems simple enough: test scores go up, pay goes up- test scores go down, pay goes down. But of course the unions will then say, again, that testing is racist. I'm surprised that teachers have to actually show up everyday at this point, a large percentage of public employees "work" from home (lol), if the "teachers" didn't show up, would there really be any effect on the (lack of) education the kids are receiving? Other than the socialist indoctrination, of course.