Washington state receives failing grade for school cellphone policies
National advocacy groups gave Washington a failing grade because the state lacks a unified policy to ban cellphones in schools.
Washington schools fail national report on cellphone policies. (Photo by Jens Kalaene/Getty Images)
(Photo by Jens Kalaene/Getty Images)
Washington state received a failing grade on a national report card because it doesn’t have a statewide ban on cellphones in schools.
While groups like The Anxious Generation push for a “gold standard” where phones are put away for the entire day, Washington’s latest law only asks for a study to be finished by 2027. Some local districts are taking matters into their own hands, but the state as a whole is being called out for moving too slowly.
A coalition of child safety organizations including Smartphone Free Childhood US, the Institute for Families and Technology, and the Becca Schmill Foundation gave Washington an “F” for its lack of strict rules on student phone use. These groups believe that phones are a huge distraction in class and that a total ban from the first bell to the last bell is the only way to help students focus. Washington is one of only five states to fail this ranking, joining Connecticut, Maryland, Mississippi, and South Dakota.
Local rules vs. state law
According to Axios Seattle, the main reason for the low grade is that the state legislature passed a law last month that doesn’t actually ban anything yet. Instead, it tells the state superintendent to look for “best practices” and report back in December 2027.
Critics, including Lina Nealon from the Institute for Families and Technology, say we already have enough evidence that phones hurt learning and that waiting for another study is just wasting time.
Even though some research shows that banning phones leads to better grades, other studies are still figuring out the exact impact on mental health. State Senator Marko Liias, who sponsored the new law, agrees that keeping phones out of school is best for learning. However, he mentioned that there weren’t enough votes in the legislature to pass a full ban yet, so he sees the current study as a starting point.
Since there is no state law yet, every school district is doing its own thing. Some Washington schools have already banned phones entirely, while others let individual principals decide. In Seattle, some schools require phones to be put away during class, but there isn’t a district-wide rule. This might change soon, as the Seattle Public Schools superintendent is set to talk about phone policies at a board meeting on April 29th.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
1 Comments
You'd think performing yet another lengthy study wouldn't be the initial response when trading education for daycare is a "today" issue. But the state, they know precisely what they're doing.