ADVERTISEMENT

EDUCATION

Study shows school COVID shutdown harms were far worse than officials claimed

A new California study, cited by the NYT, shows kids’ mental health improved sharply after schools reopened — a warning for PNW leaders who kept classrooms closed longest.

A new study confirms what conservatives warned about: COVID-era school lockdowns devastated kids. (...

A new study confirms what conservatives warned about: COVID-era school lockdowns devastated kids. (Photo: Srazen Zigic, Getty Images)

(Photo: Srazen Zigic, Getty Images)

A new peer-reviewed study shows children’s mental health improved dramatically after California schools reopened in 2021. It’s clear evidence that prolonged school closures carried far greater risks than many policymakers acknowledged at the time, despite protests from conservatives.

The New York Times, which first reported the findings, noted the research tracked 185,735 privately insured children ages 5 to 18 across the months before and after reopening. Published in the journal Epidemiology, the study found that nine months after in-person learning resumed, the likelihood a child would be seen for a mental-health condition dropped by 43 percent. Spending on mental-health medications fell 7.5 percent, and costs for therapy and similar services decreased by 10.6 percent, according to the Times.

Harvard social epidemiologist Rita Hamad, a study co-author, told the Times the data showed officials focused so heavily on transmission risk that they “failed to fully consider the social costs.” She suggested reopening decisions “may have been different” had this evidence existed earlier.

Conservatives warned of this outcome

For families in Washington state — where many public school students stayed remote until fall 2021 — the findings mirror what local parents, teachers, and clinicians have reported for years. Counselors in Seattle, Bellevue, and Tacoma all noted steep rises in anxiety and depression during the shutdown era, particularly among girls, a trend the California researchers also observed.

Some experts told the Times they believe easing safety restrictions or diminishing fear of infection contributed to the improvement. University of Oregon economist Benjamin Hansen noted the lag (most gains appeared six to nine months after reopening), but agreed in-person schooling generally benefits children.

ADVERTISEMENT

Though the authors stress school closures weren’t the sole cause of deteriorating youth mental health, the research adds to a growing national consensus that extended shutdowns harmed kids academically and emotionally without meaningfully stopping the virus’s spread.

Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.

Comments

0 Comments