Don’t retire in Tacoma, new study warns: Washington cities crowd the bottom and Idaho runs away with it
Tacoma ranked 176th of 182 cities in WalletHub's new retirement study, with Seattle, Spokane and Salem near the bottom while Boise finished 27th nationally.
A new national study ranks Tacoma among the worst cities in America for retirees. (Jason Rantz)
(Jason Rantz)
Tacoma is one of the worst places in America to retire, finishing 176th out of 182 cities in a new WalletHub study of retiree friendliness released Aug. 31. Only six cities in the country scored worse.
The study graded cities on 45 metrics grouped into affordability, activities, quality of life and health care. Tacoma came in 175th for affordability and 150th for quality of life, with a total score of 39.02 that put it behind Detroit, Riverside and Fontana, California. The city is now a fixture near the bottom of national rankings, having already been named one of the worst cities in the country for first-time home buyers at 190th out of 300 in a separate WalletHub report this summer.
Tacoma spent years selling itself as the affordable alternative to Seattle. On the measures that matter most to someone living on a fixed income, it now scores worse than the city seniors were fleeing.
Washington cities pile up near the bottom
Seattle finished 148th, Vancouver 150th and Spokane 166th. Every Washington city in the study fell in the bottom half, and the drag was almost entirely financial.
Seattle ranked 177th of 182 for affordability despite placing 27th for activities and 60th for quality of life, meaning the parks, museums and senior centers cannot offset what it costs to live there. WalletHub also listed Seattle among the most expensive cities in the country for in-home services, the kind of help aging residents need to stay in their houses. Spokane, often pitched as the budget option east of the Cascades, ranked 113th for affordability but 156th for quality of life and 147th for activities. Vancouver did well on health care at 53rd and still finished 150th overall.
Tacoma’s affordability rank of 175th is the number that should worry Pierce County. A city with a median household income well below Seattle’s is charging its retirees close to Seattle prices.
Oregon splits and Idaho runs away with it
Portland came in 68th, the best finish of any city in Washington or Oregon, carried almost entirely by its 14th place ranking for activities. Its affordability rank was 137th. Salem finished 172nd, four spots ahead of Tacoma, with a 173rd place ranking for activities.
Idaho posted the numbers Washington politicians should be reading. Boise finished 27th nationally, with a 13th place ranking for quality of life and 82nd for affordability. Nampa came in 92nd and ranked 25th for quality of life. Idaho was also ranked the best state in the country to live in a separate study earlier this year.
Orlando topped the list, followed by Miami, Tampa, Scottsdale and Casper, Wyoming. Stockton, California finished last at 182nd.
Taxes and cost of living decide these rankings
WalletHub weighted taxpayer friendliness, retired taxpayer friendliness and estate or inheritance tax treatment inside its affordability score, alongside cost of living and the price of adult day health care. Washington has no income tax (yet) and still cannot clear the bar, because sales taxes, property taxes, the capital gains tax and the estate tax all hit people who are no longer drawing a paycheck.
“It’s important to choose wisely when picking where to retire, as many retirees are on a fixed income. As a result, the best cities for retired people are those that minimize taxes and expenses, as well as have good opportunities for retirees to continue paid work for extra income, if they choose to do so. In addition, the top cities provide high-quality health care and offer plenty of enjoyable activities for retirees,” said Chip Lupo, a WalletHub analyst.
Retiring in Washington already costs more than $967,000 by one estimate, fifth highest in the nation. Seattle-area residents are responding the way you would expect, with nearly 84% of local home searches now aimed at listings outside the metro. Tacoma finished 149 spots behind Boise.
Follow Seattle Red on-air at 770 AM, on the Seattle Red app, and streaming audio and video on SeattleRed.com.






Comments
1 Comments
is anyone genuinely surprised about this